Unreliable witnesses

Last week I saw Atonement and left the cinema overwhelmed with the feeling  that I’d just witnessed a film that might  be a modern classic; a film that makes you realise you’ve been happily surviving on formulaic fast food and now you’ve had a taste of the gourmet.

I love the fact that it’s a British movie that dares to be unapologetically large scale. I love the fact that it plays narrative games and still manages to be moving. And I love the irony of a   heritage blockbuster that has the word ‘cunt’ as its major plot point.

I hadn’t seen Pride and Prejudice last year, so I knew nothing about director Joe Wright, though I remember chuckling at the trailers and thinking they’d made the mistake of filming an Austen novel as if it were a Bronte novel. It seemed far too dramatic for Austen’s acutely observed world of manners.

I guess many people who saw it  felt the same, because once I’d seen Atonement and started googling it, I was surprised to discover some venemous criticism of it. You know, the kind of criticism that seems a bit too vehement and out of place and has its roots in issues from long ago and makes the critic look like a bit of a tosser.

It’s symptomatic of a growing air of hyper-critical nonsense I’ve noticed everywhere I look these days. We live in the age of the laptop critic. In order to stand out in cyberspace you have to have an opinion. And negative opinion makes you sound more intelligent than positive opinion.

Negative opinion implies the kind of hidden intelligence and discernment that the slovenly pandering of positive opinion can only aspire to. If you want to appear intelligent, slag something off. Slag everything off. The more things you slag off, the more intelligent you will appear.

And some of the flak for Atonement on internet chat boards has been jaw-dropping in its pettiness.

According to the trolls, Atonement‘s Dunkirk scenes are ‘very unconvincing’, ‘the arrogance of the director overwhelms any tension or emotional impact’, and it all falls apart due to the ‘historical innacuracies on behalf of the director, e.g. a four-engined heavy bomber flying over England in 1935. The Dunkirk scenes were cringeworthy. Was there such strong anti-French sentiment expressed by English soldiers during the war? Questionable I’d say – more the fantasy of the director’. [All correct spelling and grammar are my own]

And so on and so forth.

Well, actually, anyone who’s studied real life accounts of the people who took part in that war (and I’ve got a shelf full of books devoted to the subject) will know that the movies of the 1950s (much as I love them) don’t really give us the true picture. The British Tommy was a far from politically correct beast. So I can quite imagine a bitter, retreating BEF squaddie slagging off the French. I’m only surprised he didn’t lay into the Jews as well, as a great many who wanted to avoid a war with Germany did at the time.

In that vein, I was particularly pleased with the stirring rendition of Fuck ’em all, which might sound anachronistic if you’re used to war movies starring Dirk Bogarde and Kenneth More but was a genuine infantry favourite of the time, as one old war veteran I once got pissed with was very fond of demonstrating at high volume. I’d always thought it was the bowdlerised version of George Formby’s ‘Bless em all’, but researching this article I’m pleased to discover that the adult version was the original.

As for the four-engined bomber flying over England in 1935, yes, it’s totally inaccurate, and I believe it’s totally deliberate. The clue is in the line about Briony being ‘an unreliable witness’.

Everything we see in  Atonement is the novel (Two Figures by a Fountain) that Briony is writing, and it contains all the historical inaccuracies a teenage girl would have committed to paper. Everything we see is her fictitious account of events, even the flashbacks to take in alternative viewpoints. Would she make the mistake of having her character gaze at an anachronistic bomber flying above? Yes, I believe she would. And that is the only reason that shot is in the film.

But it’s far too subtle a clue for the trolls, it would appear.

Having seen Atonement once, I couldn’t resist nipping back to the cinema a couple of days later to immerse myself in it again. For once, it looks like the film of the year might well be a British film. And that’s something to be proud of.

It’s a free download…

So here it is, the first of my shows from the Edinburgh International Film Festival, where I hooked up with screenwriter Paul Laverty to talk about his new film It’s A Free World and the past decade of writing screenplays with director Ken Loach.

I actually met Paul ten years ago when he came to Birmingham to do a Q&A for his first film, Carla’s Song. I was working at the Electric Cinema and grabbed the chance to be the hospitality guy who took Paul for a meal at the nearest restaurant while the film was showing. He was the first working screenwriter I’d ever talked to at length and we had a great conversation before I reluctantly took him back to the Electric for the end of the film.

He’s since written six more features with Ken Loach and his newest, It’s A Free World, wasn’t actually showing in Edinburgh (see humorous excerpt within the show) because it was premiering at the Venice Film Festival the week after. Paul was in Edinburgh for an In Person talk with festival director Hannah McGill that was absolutely packed to the rafters.

He talked about scenes from My Name is Joe, The Wind That Shakes the Barley, Sweet Sixteen and Bread and Roses, and the perils of writing politically committed cinema that’s about real characters and avoids the mere illustrating of issues.

I recorded the session and then re-introduced myself  as people piled out to ask him if he’d like to give an interview for the Shooting Screenwriters show. He was happy to but only had 10 minutes of his day free later that night before some meal he had to attend. So we hooked up later and he happily talked for half an hour before I let him go.


Paul on screenwriting courses : People seem to take great delight in knocking all these courses but I actually learned a great deal,  because I had so much to learn, and still do I think … finding out how other people do it is not a bad idea in any job, is it!

On working with Ken Loach : I suppose neither of us are great ones for the auteur theory. I’m a writer and he’s a director and we meet in the middle as filmmakers. 

On writing ‘issues’ : I don’t think a great issue makes for a great film. You have to find a subtle and unexpected way into it. But I think great issues deserve a great story.


The show  now has a svelte 30-mins-or-less time slot and you can either right-click and ‘Save target as’ to download it, or go to the Shooting People Podcasts page to subscribe for free and get future shows sent to you direct.

It’s A Free World won the Best Screenplay prize at Venice the following week and it’s being screened by Channel 4 within the next fortnight with a DVD release in October.

Edinburgh 2007

After the unbelievable hassle of vlogging from the Cheltenham Screenwriters’ Festival, I vowed that the next one would be a nice, easy written blog. And as if by magic, the Edinburgh International Film Festival announced that its theme for 2007 would be ‘cinema and the written word’.

So I set off to spend five days there, see lots of films, meet new and interesting people, and get it all down on my laptop as it happened.

I’d   had no intention of going to this festival initially as I couldn’t see that it would be any use to a screenwriter. But I caved in to persuasion from others far more knowledgeable than me and decided to go for it.

On the networking front, it wasn’t as easy as Cheltenham. There you knew that you could talk to anyone because they were either a screenwriter themselves    or they were there to meet screenwriters. In Edinburgh it’s very different and half of the people you end up talking to are little use to your career as a screenwriter.

Perhaps it might have been different if the ‘written word’ theme of the festival had delivered in any meaningful way, but that was very disappointing.

Writers know way too much about the industry and their place within it these days to be grateful for a handful of writer-director In Person sessions. That doesn’t constitute a theme. It constitutes a token gesture, and not a very convincing one at that. There were no more writer-centric events than you’d expect at any film festival.

On the whole, though, I had a positive experience. I met a lot of interesting people and saw a lot of good films, films that gave me some much needed impetus to write and sort out my own scripts.

In the end, I suppose, just being around filmmakers and films is enough for a screenwriter.

Now it’s back to those screenplays of my own…


The blog is published on the  new Festival Focus page of Shooting People’s website, and this is what I wrote about :

Yeah,   boyeeee (and shit)
I touchdown and go on a mad search for a movie fix and end up with a film about breakdancing.

You can’t fool the children of the revolution
Hungarian film about the 56 revolution, Szabadsag, Szerelem (Children of Glory), falls a bit flat, even with a magyarphile like me.

It’s a dirty job but someone’s gotta do it…
Torture porn thriller WΔZjust wasn’t, but a big party night made up for it.

And when did you last cry in a cinema?
Another Hungarian film, Kythéra, and the powerful And When Did You Last See Your Father?

Spiegel im spiegel
A night out on the town with some new friends, with shocking photographic evidence.

Sweet and deadly
UK urban thriller, Sugarhouse takes me by surprise.

Meetings with Scottish screenwriters
In which your intrepid reporter interviews Paul Laverty and hangs out with the Scottish Screenwriters group.

And the special prize goes to…
Justin Edgar’s new film, Special People, is really rather good.

The waiting is the best bit…
I go down to the basement Videotheque and watch the nice new Brit romance, The Waiting Room. It’s obviously feelgood day.

Crazy in love
Sisterly rivalry in German film Schwesterherz (Twisted Sister) and Julie Delpy being totally bonkers in her brilliant new comedy Two Days in Paris.

See you all next June
Yes, they’re taking it away from the main festival and plonking it in June, all on its own, next year.

Dial empathy for murderer…

So anyway, I finally got around to seeing Perfume tonight, and I loved it so much I want to have its babies.    

Yes, I know I was the one who ranted about the insane criminality of voice-overs that aren’t by characters within the film, but fuck it, this one works. Maybe it’s because the omniscient narrator is a pre-twentieth century literary tradition, so it seems right in a film like this for exactly the reason it feels wrong in a film like Little Children.  

The main thing that impressed me, though, was something else that’s been on my mind a lot lately, and that is making the audience empathise with characters even if they are inherently bad.

Grenouille, our ‘hero’ (to use very reductive term), kills innocent women to make perfume out of them, and yet you find yourself wanting him to succeed in his grand project, much like you almost want the killer to succeed in strangling Grace Kelly in Dial M for Murder.

Hitchcock, of course, is the master at getting you to empathise with evil, even if only briefly. He does it in Dial M for Murder, he does it in Psycho (you want that car to sink in the swamp so Norman will get away with it) and he does it in Frenzy (you want the murderer to get that tie-pin out of his victim’s hand).

So just how do you get an audience to root for your anti-hero? Well, in Perfume, there are a few crucial techniques employed.

When we first meet Grenouille, he is a new born infant struggling for life in the mud, left for dead by his mother. Not a single person in the cinema can fail to hope he draws his first breath and survives. From that moment, we’re pretty much with him.

If that’s not enough, we witness him subjected to the cruellest of upbringings: nearly murdered by fellow orphans, shunned, treated as a slave. Who could fail to want him to do well?

We also know a secret about him: his extraordinary olfactory talent. Knowing a character’s secret makes us empathise with him.

Then we see that talent go unrecognised. We know he could be the greatest perfumier in Europe, but he is condemned to be a slave.

Fake mind-readers and clairvoyants use Barnum Statements as a cold reading technique. These are statements that seem specific to you but are actually true of almost anyone. One of the key Barnum statements is ‘you are very talented but your talents aren’t recognised where you work.’ Anyone who hears that thinks ‘That’s so true!’ because everyonethinks that about themselves.

So when we see a character’s talents go unrecognised it chimes with our own deep inner need for recognition.

People who don’t understand drama think that you need to make your characters ‘sympathetic’ to get an audience to like your film. But you can get an audience to empathise with anyone, even the most evil person. All you have to do is show that character engaged in struggles that all of us have engaged in or can imagine ourselves engaged in. It’s as simple as that.

In Perfume, the writers (Andrew Birkin, Bernd Eichinger and Tom Twyker) employ empathy-inducing tactics such as basic survival, being bullied and going unrecognised.

We’ll go anywhere with a character after this array of techniques have been played on us. Anywhere at all.

This is why Perfume is  a masterclass in audience identification and I can’t recommend it enough.

The Innocents

When the Curzon Cinema in That London  announced a screening of the excellent and much overlooked Brit film The Innocents, I had to grab a   chance to rave about a little known classic.

The Innocents is one of those films you see as a kid and it leaves an indelible mark on   you. Then you catch it again as an adult and expect it to be naff, but no, it   still scares the absolute shit out of you. And not in the ‘BOO! GOTCHA!’ way of   so much horror, but in a really uneasy, creepy, hairs on the back of your neck   doing a little dance all on their own kind of way.

It’s an adaptation of the Henry James short story, The Turn of the Screw, of course, directed by Jack Clayton and beautifully shot by Freddie Francis, with a writing team composed of the formidable talents of William (I Confess) Archibald, Truman Capote and John Mortimer.

A chilling little classic that everyone should see, with a script that is   brave enough to leave us to argue for ourselves about what just happened.

If, like me, you don’t live in That London, go hire it or buy it anyway and   see how a real ghost story should be made. And if you’re lucky enough to have a   local cinema screening it, hammer their box office door down for tickets and   drag everyone you know along.

Oh, and that Rebecca‘s not bad either.

Hello, do you have a tax shelter?

How wannabe film producers get their training with EAVE

Dentists, lawyers and electricians can all  go to college to be trained in their job. In the film world you can even go to  directing school or a writing academy. But no one teaches you how to be a film  producer. It’s just something you learn to do when you balls it up as a  director, isn’t it?

Okay, that’s a joke, but the point remains  that you can do film school if you want to direct, or take any one of the  Writing MAs that have sprung up around the country if you want to be a  scriptwriter; but what do you do if you want to be a producer?

Well, the answer is, you go to EAVE, and,  to my surprise, that’s been the tried and tested route for over a decade now.  EAVE (pronounced ‘Ee-ah-vay’), in fact, seems to be the European film  industry’s best kept secret, having not only developed a great many European  films over the years, but also trained most of Europe’s film producers.  Suddenly, having attended one of their workshops for a week, I find that most  of the producers I meet are EAVE graduates. It’s like discovering some secret  brotherhood like the Masons or the Rosicrucians. They’re everywhere.

Committing to EAVE means taking three  week-long workshops over the space of a year, each one in a different European  city. The first workshop will be concerned with Development and most producers  go with a scriptwriter to kick a project into shape. The second workshop will  train participants in Packaging and Finance. Finally, the third workshop is a  monster pitching session where you get to try and sell your project to scores  of top producers.

It’s not just three weeks’ work, though. In  between workshops you’ll be developing your project whilst liaising with your  group leader and specialist experts. EAVE also means accepting that you will  spend a whole year on the film festival circuit. So you’re pretty much  committed to spending twelve months of your life schmoozing with the  cigar-chomping top brass of Eurofilm Incorporated.

It’s a hefty commitment to make, but the  effect is clear for anyone to see. This year EAVE came to Birmingham for the  first time, with the third workshop of the 2003 course, so I got an insight  into just how valuable an experience it can be.

First off, I’m a screenwriter, so it’s  interesting for me to see the producer’s angle on things. Secondly, my God –  look how many of them there are! For a whole week I’m surrounded by up to sixty  movie producers. It’s more producers than I’ve seen in my life so far. Do I  have enough business cards with me?

It’s not just that I’m hob-nobbing with the  next generation of continental movie producers; it’s also that a few of the  current generation of quite famous movie producers are here as well. I do a bit  of a double take when I find myself standing on the terrace of Ipanema and  realise that the lanky, slightly frayed at the edges guy I’m chatting to is  actually Nik Powell. You know, the guy who set up Virgin with Branson, then  went on to exec produce films like Company  of Wolves, Letter to Brezhnev, Mona Lisa, Scandal, Waterland, The Crying Game,  Backbeat, Fever Pitch and Little  Voice. Yeah, that Nik Powell.

But that kind of schmooze coup is par for  the course. A year on EAVE and you’ll have met nearly everyone who’s anyone on  the European film scene.

Mark Pressdee is finding that out. He’s  spent the past few years working on nearly every low/no-budget short film  production in the West Midlands and, consequently, has one of the most sought  after filofaxes in the local film industry. He already spends a large part of  his day fielding calls from frantic local line-producers who desperately need  runners, DOPs or lighting crews for the short they’re shooting, especially when  it’s First Cut or Digital Shorts time. But now he’s decided to become a bona  fide producer and has gone through the EAVE mill, emerging with an exhausted  look and a graduation certificate for his production office wall.

“It’s totally changed me,” says Mark. “This  year I’ve been to every film festival in Europe except, ironically, Edinburgh,  I’ve pitched my project idea in Cannes, I’ve just spent a week here in  Birmingham pitching to some of the biggest producers in Europe and some of them  are interested in the feature I’ve got. It’s the kind of experience that  changes you totally as a person. I actually feel like a film producer now. For  a giggle I even made the odd appearance in a suit and with a cigar! Seriously,  though, it filled me with self-believe. I now know I can push my projects. I  now believe in my talent as a producer to develop and nurture the talent of the  region, because that’s what it’s all about.”

It’s funny, but, because I know Mark, it’s  easier to see the real effect EAVE can have on a person. He walks taller, he  has more stature, because yes, he’s a producer now.

“I think I’ve probably just  taken a leap forward by six years. If I hadn’t done EAVE, I know it would have  taken me another six years to learn what I’ve just learned. When I went to the  first workshop back in January, I talked to a local producer who’d done it the  year before (Natasha Carlish, who recently produced the short film, Bouncer) and she said I’d come back to  Birmingham and immediately set up an office. I was like, you must be joking, I  can’t afford that, but she just smiled and said I would. So I do the first  workshop in Ludwigsburg and come straight back and take a unit in the Custard  Factory. I had to. You can’t be a producer without a production office.”

Doing the course has set him back a bit:  something like two grand from his pocket and maybe another three grand of work  that he had to turn down in order to do the festivals, but he got help to fund  some of it and he knows it’s an investment in his career. A year ago his  contacts book was full of regional talent and he was working on no-budget  shorts; now his contacts book is full of European producers and he’s talking to  the big money people about his feature idea. The next stage is to use those  European contacts to get movies off the ground in the West Midlands: a marriage  of continental and regional talent.

Mark is now doing business as Macoy Media.

Workshop 3, which took place largely at  Birmingham Rep, was hosted by Screen West Midlands and featured a number of  plenaries that were open to local producers. Of particular interest was the  talk given by Alison Small, Head of Film Council International, who pointed out  that inward-investment features in the UK are about to break all records.  There’s never been a better time to be a British producer looking for European  co-production partners to shoot a movie: “Global filmmaking is here to stay and  it’s not a threat to the UK that there are all these other fantastic filmmaking  centres across Europe: we should be working with each other in partnership.”

EAVE, then, seems like the perfect place to  start making those partnerships.


A version of this first appeared on Channel 4’s Ideasfactory site.