The turn of the screwball

There was a time when the word ‘screwball’ conjured up a plastic cone of cheap ice cream with a ball of chewing gum at the bottom.  Mine were served to me by Anita, the young woman who once got bollocked by our headmaster for exploiting us kids by parking her ice cream van at the school gates every lunch time. He didn’t know we wanted to be exploited by Anita… and that it was more about her hotpants and pigtails than her ice cream.

It was all there: the taste of the forbidden, incipient sexual attraction in denial and the chasm between, sprinkled with the hundreds and thousands of absurdity. I was an 11 year-old boy and Anita was a really old woman (possibly in her 20s!) – it was not to be.

It was only later, when I was as ancient as Anita, that I discovered a different kind of screwball: a bunch of romantic comedy satires mainly made in the 1930s. Films like His Girl Friday, Bringing Up Baby, The Awful Truth, Nothing Sacred, My Man Godfrey, The Shop Around The Corner and It Happened One Night.

These are ‘sex comedies without the sex’, of course, but they do several very specific things: they are always about a couple who sublimate loving for fighting, there’s always some kind of social barrier to them being together, they are always about a kooky, chaotic woman who destroys the well-ordered, logical world of an uptight man and makes him more human in the process. And the dialogue is always razor sharp, ultra-witty and delivered at high speed.

Screwball is often confused with romantic comedy, but the two are quite distinct. Screwball is a parody of romcom. Screwball characters fall in love, of course, but they don’t make a big deal out of it: no big speeches, no earnest entreaties, no passionate climaxes. They just admit they’re in love and carry on arguing. Screwball satiriseslove. (Maybe that’s why I’ve always liked it).

This is why When Harry Met Sally is a romcom, not a screwball. It dances around in Screwball’s shoes for a long time, but in the end it kicks them off and goes for the great big earnest climax (I love that film, but I hate that ending). As Wes D. Gehring puts it, ‘The screwball genre always accents the silly over the sentimental.’

Miss Pettigrew Lives For a Day tries damned hard to dance in Screwball’s shoes. Amy Adams takes her charmingly deluded princess character from Enchanted and turns it all the way up to 11 as Delysia Lafosse, an airhead socialite It Girl stringing three guys along and dreaming of making it big on the stage. Katherine Hepburn and Rosalind Russell would approve.  She is a scat-brained force of nature.

But whereas in a proper screwball, she would be the catalyst for change in others, in this film she is the one who needs to make a fateful decision: to choose true love over career advancement. Katherine Hepburn and Rosalind Russell would definitely not approve.

In fact, while Miss Pettigrew looks like a classic 30s Screwball comedy, it’s not really about a man and a woman fighting in love at all: it’s about two women coming together to change each other’s lives on a single fateful day.

The fact that it veers from the screwball template doesn’t mean it is somehow wrong, or an indication of bad screenwriting. It isn’t. Genres change and adapt and merge. I’m more interested in looking at how it differs from the classic screwball it appears to be at first glance in order to understand the process a bit more.

Blake Snyder‘s Story Types are useful here. All screwballs, along with all romcoms and a great many more genres fall into the Buddy Love story type. But Miss Pettigrew seems to be more of a Fool Triumphant story, with Frances McDormand playing the gauche outsider who accidentally finds herself in a highly superficial world and becomes its master through her natural talent for honesty.

By placing so much emphasis on this strand, the screwball element is diluted. Plus, Miss Pettigrew is anything but satirical about love, even though it likes to dress up in Screwball’s clothes.

This is most obvious in the show-stopping central duet, If I Didn’t Care. Ignoring the fact that no singer in 1939 would have sung it like that without being kicked out of the door and their performance seems to have somehow been beamed in from 20 or 30 years in the future,   this is the moment where the kookiness gives way to heartfelt emotion.

It seems that the only thing up for satire in this film is false love, not true love.

What I said last week about an audience’s need to feel certain emotions is relevant here.      Miss Pettigrew Lives For A Day works because, despite all its uncertainty with genre and its atrocious  anachronistic murdering of the music I love, it delivers emotions that an audience wants to feel.

Would it be over-stating things to draw parallels between its Depression-era rags to riches tale of hope and the Credit Crunched market in which it finds itself?

Maybe not.

It’s definitely no Screwball, but it’s fun, sweet and  a pleasant enough diversion.   A bit like the ones Anita used to serve up.

Once more with feeling…

It was the sleeper hit of 2007. The little movie that could. The ultra-low budget verite romance about a busker and an immigrant falling in love and making sweet music together. It was shot on the streets of Dublin for $120k and made $9.7 million worldwide, got into every film critic’s Top Ten list, wowed them at Sundance, and pocketed an Oscar for Best Song. Everything about this movie screams massive success. So why do so many people come away from it feeling so frustrated?

[This article discusses the ending of the movie. If you haven’t watched it and don’t want it spoiled, it’s time to stop reading. Come back when you’ve seen it.]

I tried to see Onceat the Edinburgh Film Festival last year, but only just missed out on its screening. Everyone was talking about it, though. I then went and missed it at the cinema too. Maybe I blinked. It came and went at my local multiplex with the unseemly haste of an absolute stinker, which took me by surprise. I’d never seen a bad review of it, but it looked like it had been pulled because no one was bothering    to turn up for it in its first week. What was going on?

It may seem churlish to pick fault with a movie that has made such a massive profit, but when you look at its placing in the worldwide box office and compare it to the movies around it, you start to wonder why it did so badly.

Once sits in roughly the same company as In The Valley of Elah, Rendition and Oncehas exactly the same appeal.

This doesn’t make sense. We’re talking about the feelgood film of the year. Just look at the trailer:

How could you not be beguiled by that?

Well, perhaps the answer is in how the film ends. And here’s the big spoiler: they don’t get together in the end.

Say what? Are you fucking kidding me?

Yep. Straight up. Even though the script has gone to great pains to set up  how inappropriate their other options are for them (he’s still hurting from his ex who went and ‘screwed some other guy’     and she has a husband back home who is too old and has no emotional connection with her), even though she actually tells him ‘I love you’ at one point (in Czech, untranslated and not subtitled), even though we know deep down that these two people, despite their own fears, are perfect for each other… it ends with her husband coming over to live with her, and our wussbag hero buying her the piano she longs for with all his money as he fucks off to London with a smug smile on his fizzog to go and get that old girlfriend back.

Glen Hansard is on record as saying he wouldn’t have spent so much time promoting the movie if they’d had a happy ending forced on them (see good old Wikipedia), and it’s a view supported by the movie critics and a vocal minority of fans. But this is just cutting off  box office nose to spite Hollywood face. It’s what every arthouse film bore bleats about all the time: happy endings aren’t real life; they are just Hollywood bullshit.

Apparently, in the real world, people don’t fall in love and make a commitment to be together even though it flies in the face of all their other irritating responsibilities. It just never happens!

(Right now I’m picturing that rant by Robert McKee in the film Adaptationabout things that happen every fucking day in the real fucking world, and I hope you are too.)

The fact is, you can’t set up a love story like that and then deny the audience the ending you’ve set up for them because you have some ridiculously misguided notion about what doesn’t happen in the real world (actually , you can, and you can even get an Oscar for it, but audiences aren’t fooled by that shit).

What’s happening here is genre betrayal: starting to tell one kind of story, then screwing the audience over with a resolution that bears no relation to it. It’s nothing to do with real life. It’s just bad storytelling.

Onceis a love story till right at the end, when it mugs us with an outbreak of common sense that betrays everything we’ve felt about these characters. And it’s pretty clear that word of mouth got round that the ‘feelgood hit of the year’ may have made movie critics feel good about themselves but wasn’t so feelgood for the rest of us.

The only reason I feel angry about it is because Once is a good film.   I like the two central characters; I love how they can only reveal their true feelings through the songs they sing together; I love the raw power of those songs (the first time they sing Falling Slowly together and the recording of  When Your Mind’s Made Upare absolutely electric moments); I love them so much I feel betrayed by the totally false resolution imposed on them.

It’s not big and it’s not clever.     And, for once, I’m actually welcoming the Hollywood remake.