Touchstone (1. The Sins of the Fathers)

One touch… and you’re who knows when?

Rachel: the dirt poor girl brought up by her single parent father.

Danny: the arrogant rich kid who has everything his wealthy parents can afford.

Two History students who wouldn’t normally mix, but whose lives become entwined when an old gravestone catapults them back in time.

In 1912, they explore their city’s dark past, a gritty, violent, gaslit world of real danger, and try to prevent the murder of a teenage girl at the hands of her abusive, syphilitic father.

But they find that every action has an unforeseen consequence that can ripple through generations.  Continue reading →

Why Hollywood wants your ebook

Today is a day of conflicting emotions. You see, my good friend Jonathan Turner, the man who wrote the best spec script I’ve ever read, is at the 2011 Screenwriting Expo in LA, and I was supposed to be there with him.

I don’t feel too bad. It wasn’t a concrete promise. In fact, it’s something we’ve promised each other to do every year since we met, rather like the Jews of the diaspora who every Passover say ‘next year in Israel’. One day we were going to go to that Expo in Hollywood, and this year looked odds on to be the year.

But then the ebook thing happened and I found myself working exclusively on publishing 11 titles before 11.11.11, so I had to tell Jonathan, ‘You know what? I don’t think I can do it this year. Maybe next time.’

It made sense that he should go because he was armed with two absolutely knockout action thrillers that were just made for Hollywood, whereas I was a novelist working so hard on ebook titles I wondered if I’d ever have time for screenwriting again. But isn’t it always the way that, as soon as you turn away from that thing you’ve been chasing all your life and say ‘Oh screw you, I’ve got better things to do,’ that thing comes running up and taps you on the shoulder and says ‘I’m here.’

What happened was that, just as I’d almost given up on screenwriting and started to think of myself as more of a novelist again, I got an email from a Hollywood producer asking to buy the rights to The Very Thought of You, my timeslip ghost story that had only been published a month and sold a couple of dozen copies. Continue reading →

The Very Thought of You

What happens when you fall in love with a woman who died before you were born?

The Very Thought of You is a timeslip ghost story novella about a young man’s obsession with Amy, the dead wife of an old man he visits.

Community visitor Jez is assigned Harold, a cantankerous old codger who takes a venomous delight in confrontation and lives in a house that is falling down around him. But when Jez starts to see Amy’s ghost and finds himself propelled into the house’s secret past, his obsession with her threatens his hold on the present.

The Very Thought of You is a moving, evocative meditation on love and betrayal and the persistence of memory. Continue reading →

Love me one time, baby

Anyone who’s ploughed through this site will know that I’ve got a bit of a thing for time travel stories, as well as a penchant for romcoms and tragic love stories like Somewhere in Time. So it’s no surprise that I was pretty eager to see the long-delayed movie adaptation of Audrey Niffeneggar’s smash hit faux-lit novel The Time Traveler’s Wife.   And, despite the sickly trailer, it doesn’t disappoint.

Bruce Joel Rubin has done a great job distilling the novel’s sprawling scope to its essential elements without losing the sense of epic tragedy at its heart.

But where I chiefly find the film fascinating is in the question of genre, and where it stands in the particular genre of the Tragic Love Story (which I’ll call TLS from now on, if you don’t mind).

When I want to know more about a genre I go to two people. One is the late Blake Snyder. His 10 Story Types are great for getting a handle on what a particular genre is really all about, but I don’t think he fully nailed the TLS, which he tends to categorise under ‘Epic Love’, and I’d like to see it recognised as a sub-set all of its own, because maybe not all TLSS are epic.

The other person I go to is the Script Factory’s Lucy Scher, who’s made something of a specialty of studying genre and championing its importance with UK screenwriters.

In her excellent article Love on Screen: Romantic Comedies and Tragic Love Stories, she pinpoints the crucial differences between these two ‘chick flick’ staples. Yes, they are both about two people that the audience  want to be   together who suffer obstacles to their union.

But in romcoms it’s the present situation of the characters which is   important. The obstacles to the union of our two main characters are situational   and/or internal to the characters and are invested with humour… which is why we don’t need to know much about their lives, backgrounds or how they came to be the people they are. They’re usually products of their time, and they’re two people who don’t want to be together.

In the Tragic Love Story it is the lovers who want to be together and   this is a key and significant difference. The obstacles are that one or both of   the protagonists are violating and disregarding the power structures in their   lives by pursuing the union… Therefore, we do need a wealth of information   about the background of the characters in order to understand why the stakes are   so high.

In most TLSS, the obstacle is class. This is why so many TLSS are set in the past. Class was much more of an obstacle then than it is now. It’s harder for us to accept it as a major obstacle these days, especially one with tragic potential.

While Romeo And Juliet and West Side Story could make do with the  class conflict of rival families/gangs that must never mix, most of the great  TLSS offer class and one other conflict to create tragedy: Love Story (class and cancer), A Walk To Remember (class and leukemia), Titanic (class and drowning), The Notebook (class and dementia). .

So how do you write a TLS in an age when no one cares about class?

The answer is to be found in other genres. Bruce Joel Rubin was onto this a long time ago when he created a smash hit by going the supernatural  route with his screenplay Ghost, in which it’s not lovers transgressing the social divide that leads to tragic death; it’s tragic death that leads to lovers transgressing the divide between this world and the next.

A more popular route at the moment seems to be science-fiction, in particular, time travel. Look at the recent successes of The Curious Case Of Benjamin Button (how can love survive when he’s ageing backwards?), The Lake House (how can love survive when he’s two years in the future?), Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind (how can love survive when she keeps having her memories of you erased?), and now The Time Traveler’s Wife (how can love survive when he suffers from chrono-impairment and keeps disappearing to other moments in his life?).

The reason time travel offers such fertile ground for the TLS is that it can explore what love means when pitted against the random nature of the universe, and that’s much closer to how we feel about the world these days than outmoded notions of class.

Judith Maas, reviewing Audrey Niffeneggar’s novel in The Boston Globe, notes that ‘time travel becomes a means for representing arbitrariness, transience, plain   bad luck.’ It’s love struggling against a hostile cosmos, but in this instance it’s something more. Natasha Walter in The   Guardian refers to ‘the sense of slippage that   you get in any relationship—that you could be living through a slightly   different love story from the one your partner is experiencing.’

Choosing to write a TLS over a romcom is a risky venture. By its nature, it’s not going to have an entirely happy ending, and there can be a fear of that in the commercial film world. People are supposed to like happy endings. Well, they don’t. Not always.

The highest grossing film of all time is a tragic love story (Titanic) and another is the highest ticket-selling film of all time in North America and the UK (Gone With The Wind).

The Time Traveler’s Wife won’t quite be doing the same business but it’s a decent addition to an important genre that is all too often overlooked.

The time traveller’s strife…

Journeyman, the  NBC drama series starring Kevin McKidd, has already featured here in my Top 25 Time Travel Stories, but it deserves a closer look, seeing as it was one of the stand out dramas of the Fall schedule and is still running on Sky over here in the UK.

What at first looked like a gimmicky Quantum Leap rip off turned out to be a moving drama about how a disorder like involuntary time travel can affect a marriage. No surprise then, that the show was created by Kevin Falls, who’s had writing and exec roles on quality drama series like Sports Night, The West Wing and Shark.

Kevin McKidd stars as Dan Vasser, a San Francisco reporter who suffers from chrono-displacement (to borrow a term from Audrey Niffenegger’s novel The Time-Traveler’s Wife): randomly finding himself catapulted into his own past. But there appears to be some kind of controlling intelligence at work: Dan is there to help someone and change something, which is where the Quantum Leap comparisons come in.

Journeyman is much more intelligent than Quantum Leap, though, and there’s a compelling series arc in which we never quite get to find out who’s controlling Dan’s jaunts (a revelation they were perhaps saving for episode 21).

Kevin Falls has acknowledged the comparisons, though he stresses he’s never read The Time-Traveler’s Wife: ‘The issue was more of the domestic problem of time traveling and its impact   on the marriage, I think we kind started there ‘cause we wanted it to start with   how it would feel to a family, and then get into more of the mythology of it.   But once we got deeper into it, all that stuff fell away. And the Quantum Leap comparison hung around for a while, and then   that fell away, and it seemed like everybody kind of realized it was its own   show.’

Journeyman suffered in the ratings war but managed to complete its 13-episode initial run with a few questions answered, much in the manner that Heroes tried to wind things up for its half season run. The reason for this is the WGA Writers Strike. Shows don’t know if they’re going to come back or not.

Ironically, though, the strike may have helped Journeyman. Its pilot episode was perhaps too complex and viewers dropped away, but those that stuck with it saw it develop quickly into a compelling drama. If the strike hadn’t been on, NBS may well have pulled it earlier.

But Journeyman now seems to have gone the same way as that other high quality NBC show, Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip: screwed over because the network never bothered to push it in the proper timeslot, although  Falls was quick to point out that NBC gave Studio 60 a much bigger push than   they gave Journeyman, which achieved the same ratings on a fraction of the promotion.

Although no official cancellation has been announced, NBC allowed their full season pick-up option to lapse, which means actors and crew are now free to look for other work. In the eyes of many, this means the show is effectively dead, much to the anger of the millions who love it.

The only winners in this might be The Quaker Oats Company. Outraged Journeyman fans have emulated the actions of the Jericho supporters who got CBS to re-order that show by deluging them with peanuts. The Save Journeyman campaign are sending NBS executives boxes of the San Francisco snack Rice a Roni.

Hopefully, they’ll get the message. Or another network that is less prone to premature cancellations will see the massive support out there for quality, intelligent drama and pick it up themselves… once the strike is over, of course.


The Greatest Time Travel Stories

We all have those genres  in which we’ll watch anything just because it’s that genre, and my particular generic addiction is time travel stories, of which there are some great movies and novels and some utterly cheesy ones. I don’t care. I consume them all like a crackhead, even when they fail miserably.

My obsession with this genre led me to writing my own time travel fiction series, Touchstone, so to research the genre I’ve watched a lot of old movies and delved into a great many novels, just to see how other writers handle it.

So here’s my list of favourites.

Andy’s Anachronisms (nothing to do with me) is an interesting site that attempts to categorise the different types of time travel story, so I’ll use his labels (even though some of the stories are very slippery and could belong in more than one).

Standard Time Travel   (where characters are transported into the future/past instantaneously)

The Time Tunnel (1966-7)
No one who grew up watching TV in the 70s can forget this Irwin Allen produced drama in which two  scientists who look like catalogue models are ‘lost in the swirling maze of past and future ages’ when Project Tic-Toc  goes terribly wrong… which means they end up in history’s most exciting places just before imminent disaster: the Titanic, the Alamo, Krakatoa, Pearl Harbour, Little Bighorn… you get the idea. [ Titles + Trailer ]

Timeslip (1970)
I also grew up on this children’s TV series from the 70s, with its bewildering criss-crossing between past, present and future via a force field in an abandoned military base. I watched it all again on DVD recently and it hasn’t aged well, but its concepts were years ahead of its time (longevity drugs, global warming, cloning) and I can still remember the terror I felt when that woman in the ice station prematurely aged.

Time and Again (1970)
Jack Finney’s novel has a disillusioned illustrator recruited for a secret government project training subjects to hypnotise themselves into the past. Si Morley starts to successfully visit 1882 New York and becomes involved in a squalid blackmail plot and the Great Park Row Fire. The wealth of detail is overwhelming and sometimes too much, but it’s gripping and the illustrations are a nice, if unusual, touch.

Time After Time (1979)
HG Wells (Malcolm McDowell) has built a real working time machine in his cellar and is about to demonstrate it when Jack the Ripper, one of his dinner guests, uses it to escape the police. If only my dinner parties were that exciting. Thinking he’s unleashed a monster on ‘utopia’, Wells travels to 1979 New York in order to track  down the Whitechapel murderer… and fall in love with Mary Steenburgen in the process. Who wouldn’t? She’s gorgeous!

Somewhere in Time (1980)
There are so many reasons to hate this: I’m not a Christopher Reeve fan, I hate everything Jane Seymour’s ever been in, and it’s absolutely corny and should be a disaster on so many levels. But it works and it’s beautiful. Reeve is convincing as the playwright willing himself back in time to romance the actress whose aged self urged him to ‘Come back to me’. And Jane Seymour gives the performance of her life without ever once acting. Her face is glacial and we’re as hynotised by it as Reeve is.

The Black and Blue Lamp (1988)
A single drama by Arthur Ellis that I caught one night on BBC2, not expecting much, and after an hour thought I’d seen the best black comedy in TV history. Tom Riley, the villain who murders PC George Dixon in classic 40s film The Blue Lamp, is arrested and, due to some unexplained temporal error, ends up in an episode of The Filth, a gritty 1990s cop show. At the same time the 1990s Riley, a foul-mouthed modern killer, ends up in the 1940s police cell being offered a cup of tea and a bun. What ensues is comedy genius. You can’t get it on DVD or VHS so it only exists as part of a Listener review and a lengthy article from the Illustrated Gazette.

Goodnight Sweetheart (1993-9)
Marks and Gran’s time travel bigamist sitcom, in which Nicholas Lyndhurst discovers a portal back to wartime London and flits between then and 90s Britain, was always hugely popular but critically underrated. Its 58 episodes were endlessly inventive and pushed the boundaries of the genre (there was even a multiple selves outbreak at one point) but were always funny.
Gary: My wives exist in different temporal aspects of a four-dimensional space-time continuum.
Ron: Typical bigamist’s excuse.

The Terminator (1984 – 2003)
A killer robot from the future is sent back to murder the mother of our future rebel leader. The first movie is faultless. The second made it look amateurish. The third and fourth parts remain entertaining as long as they keep John Connor’s emotions to the fore, but were largely outclassed by the brilliant TV series: Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles. Utterly brilliant on every level.

Back to the Future (1985 – 1990)
It’s impossible to talk about time travel movies without mentioning this trilogy, even though it doesn’t excite me like most others. But it’s fun and clever and the second one is far and away the best, whatever anyone says, purely because it  stretches the imagination so much and involves Marty going back in time to avoid himself going back in time from the previous movie.

12 Monkeys (1995)
It’s fashionable to slag this off and I have no idea why. Bruce Willis is great as the future convict sent back to gather information on the virus that wiped out humanity. Right from the start there is no hope of anything ever being changed for the better and the denouement plays out with a terrible inevitability.
[ Trailer ]

Deja Vu (2006)
A nice twist on the genre as boffins devise an Einstein-Rosen bridge that can view anything in New Orleans precisely four days and six hours ago, and draft in ATF agent Doug Carlin (Denzel Washington) to prevent a terrorist attack. Naturally, he falls in love with the dead girl he’s tracking and, naturally, sends himself back in time to rescue her. The sequence where he drives through daylight streets chasing the suspect who’s driving home at night four days ago has got to be the most mind-bending car chase ever filmed. [ Trailer ]

Life on Mars (2006 – 2007)
Rejected by almost every drama commissioning editor in British TV over a nine year period and an instant hit once it aired, this time-travel-meets-police-procedural genre mash-up got it so right. British drama is afraid of sci-fi. British drama is afraid of high-concept. But this story of a modern by-the-book policeman who is suddenly transported to 1973 and the squad of a tough, rule-bending, old school copper managed to be everything that its more left field ‘serious’ competition aspired to be: gritty, moving and relevant.


PAH (Personal Alternate History) 

It’s a Wonderful Life (1946)
The grandaddy of all PAH adventures. Anyone who dismisses this as sentimental goo clearly has never bothered to watch the Pottersville sequence, where the dark heart of America is laid bare and George Bailey sees how catastrophic a world in which he’d never been born really is. And if you don’t care about Zuzu’s petals, your life has no meaning.

Sliding Doors (1998)
Gwyneth Paltrow’s life takes two radically different paths based on whether she does or doesn’t catch her tube and get home early to discover her boyfriend sin bed with another woman.   It’s rare to find a British movie that’s this confident with genre, particularly a double genre hybrid like this, and it’s a great script by Peter Howitt that resolves both alternate realities with a neat twist.

Run Lola Run (1998)
The three alternate realities don’t quite make sense if you look closely, as the distractions and obstacles on Lola’s runs don’t actually seem to affect things, but it’s hard not to love the sheer energy of a film that  delivered a defibrillating shock of energy to a German cinema that had flatlined years before.

The Butterfly Effect (2004)
Or ‘Dude. Where’s My Arms?’ as I  prefer to call it. Ashton Kutcher finds that his adolescent journals propel him back in time to his childhood blackouts (if only teenage diaries were really that useful), where he tries to fix the effects of his meddling, each time with some disastrous result for him or his friends. The ‘Manhattan’ ending (rather than the alternate ’embryo’ ending) is a piece of poetry.

A Life Interrupted, from The 4400 season 2   (2005)
This little known TV series about returned alien abductees with special powers was blown out of the water by the first season of Heroes, but carried on for four quietly impressive seasons like the little engine that could. In this Emmy-worthy episode, written by Ira Steven Behr, NTAC investigator Tom wakes up to a world where the 4400 never happened, his troubled son is happy and he’s also married to a rocket-fit Italian chick called Alana. As personal alternate histories go, he’s landed a beaut. It takes him eight years to find out how to get back to his old crappy life. But wouldn’t you just stay?


Rip Van Winkel  (a person frozen in time awakes to find themself in the future)

In truth, this particular sub-genre doesn’t really interest me. Idiocracy  (2006) was a recent example, and a decent comedy, and we have Enchanted in cinemas this Xmas, but they don’t really possess the same emotional power as the other examples.


Alternate Universe (multiple universes or multiple selves from parallel worlds)

The Man Who Folded Himself (1973)
There aren’t many of these around, but this novel by David Gerrold, although it starts off with the most crass of premises (a time travelling belt?), evolves into a bewildering meditation on time and identity as Daniel’s increasingly narcissistic selves multiply and cross-cut. Sex with yourself? How about an orgy? Don’t tell me you wouldn’t as well.

Fatherland (1992)
Robert Harris’s bestselling thriller wonders what 1964 Berlin would look like if Hitler had won the war. But it’s not merely skillful alternate universe-rendering, as impressive as that is here; it’s a tense thriller about Xavier March, a low level detective investigating the death of a high-ranking war hero (or old nazi in our world) and a political scandal that concerns Nazi officials who attended a meeting at Wannsee in 1942. What could have been on the agenda?


Temporal Phenomenom  (anomolies such as time loops and other storytelling devices that involve some manipulation of time)

This is the most interesting area of time travel drama for me. These tend to concern individuals who experience timeslips. It’s obvious that the whole idea of involuntary time travel as some kind of medical abnormality (Chrono-Displacement, if you will) is fast becoming a modern preoccupation.

Time and the Conways (1937)
One of several stage plays by JB Priestley that explored his fascination with  theories of time (An Inspector Calls is the most famous).  This play explores JW Dunne‘s theory of simultaneous time, and concerns the bitter future awaiting the Conway family, as glimpsed in premonition by the heroine Kay during a fateful birthday party. There was a BBC adaptation in 1985 but it has never been released on DVD.

Replay (1987)
In this novel by Ken Grimwood, Jeff Winston dies of a heart attack and finds himself catapulted back into his teenage body with all his adult memories intact, to live his life again with the ability to avoid all his previous mistakes. Each ‘replay’ manages to be engrossing in its own way, but he re-emerges into life always at a later date than before (so his lives are getting worryingly shorter), until the novel’s mid-point, when he discovers a woman who is experiencing the exact same phenomenon. They become lovers desperately trying to find each other through the years, both aware, ironically, that time is running out for them. A cult classic that transcends the genre. Beautiful.

Groundhog Day (1993)
Bill Murray’s finest hour as the cynical TV reporter who finds himself reliving the same day over and over again. The premise is fantastic and deftly handled, and it’s so right that no explanation for the time glitch is given. A great comedy that raises profound philosophical questions, which is what Hollywood is supposed to be incapable of. The script is so  good even Andie McDowall can’t ruin it.

12.01 (1993)
A TV movie that came out the same year as Groundhog Day and disappeared without a trace. There are many similarities, even though the cause of the time loop is explained rationally. It’s not quite as genius as Groundhog Day, but it’s charming and funny and even moving in places. Criminally underrated.

The Fermata (1994)
Nicholson Baker’s sci-fi-meets-posh-porn novel is about a lowly office temp, Arno Strine, who has the ability to stop time with a click of his fingers, during which pause (or fermata) he can get work done or, more often, remove women’s underwear and write lengthy pieces of erotica for them. His descriptions of life in the ‘Fold’ are beautifully tender.

The Time-Traveler’s Wife (2004)
Published 17 years after Replay and very similar in tone, if not  form, Audrey Niffenegger’s novel hit the best sellers list in 2004. An unconventional love story about a Chicago librarian with a genetic disorder (Chrono-Displacement) that causes him to time travel when he is stressed. This one crossed over because it’s just as much romance as it is sci-fi. [see my article on the film and the Tragic Love Story genre].

The Lake House (2006)
Adapted from the South Korean film, Il Mare (2000), this is a mindbender with a heart, as the chronologically-crossed lovers romance each other through a gap of two years by way of letters left in a shared mail box. Sandra Bullock invests the film with an overwhelming air of melancholy with a career best performance and David Auburn’s script is a Gordian knot of near misses and half chances. It really is quite special.

Blink (2007)
Ironic that the Greatest Dr Who Episode Ever hardly features the titular time traveller. Steven Moffat’s ‘Dr lite’ episode is all about creepy ‘quantum locked’ statues that feed off our energy and can catapult us back in time with a touch. Moffat plays the time travel game like an expert and there are some head spinning moebius strip moments, not least of which is the superb DVD easter eggs contrivance. A modern masterpiece and the best thing on UK telly all year. Just don’t blink. Ever.

Journeyman (2007)
Yet another example of Chrono-Displacement. Kevin McKidd stars as a journalist in San Francisco who finds himself flung back to earlier parts of his life (luckily, he can arrive wearing his clothes and any objects he has about his person, unlike Henry in The Time-Traveler’s Wife who has to go naked and minus the fillings in his teeth). His jaunts seem to centre around a person he needs to help, Quantum Leap style, so they aren’t merely random. This promising series was dropped by NBC after 13 episodes despite a fan campaign to save it. They haven’t even put it out on DVD, although it is available to view on Hulu.  See my longer review here… [ Trailer ]


For an exhaustive listing of time travel movies and TV shows, have a look at The Big List.

And if you’ve enjoyed this look at all things time travel, check out my Touchstone time travel saga.

The first book – Touchstone (1. The Sins of the Fathers) is available free in ebook. In the first part, Touchstone (1. The Sins of the Fathers) , a pair of mismatched History students, Rachel and Danny, find themselves catapulted back to 1912 Birmingham and become involved in a dangerous mission to prevent the murder of teenage girl, Amy Parker. They quickly discover that their city’s dark past is a gritty world of real danger where every action has an unforeseen consequence that can ripple through generations.

Timeslip sliding away…

About ten years ago, when I first got my screenwriting bug and became something of a film buff, I used to record almost every film on TV and became intimately acquainted with a lot of obscure movies. I still have a VHS collection   of some 600 titles. It was about this time that I fell in love with a little known timeslip romance called Portrait of Jennie, and instantly installed it in my personal Top Ten. It pains me to say that, because I watched it again last night and discovered that it’s rubbish.

I watched it again because I’m preparing an article on my favourite time travel stories (yours to read here  in the near future) as well as writing my own time travel drama series, so I thought I should reacquaint myself with it. After all, I haven’t watched it again since its inauguration in my Top Ten a decade ago and it surely can’t go the way of that other film that I discovered wasn’t half as good as I thought it was on second viewing, could it? (Jacques Demy’s Lola, since you ask).

What attracted me to Portrait of Jennie to begin with was that it was an intriguing story about a couple that conduct a relationship through some kind of timeslip. Eben Adams (Joseph Cotten) is a starving and not very good artist in 1948 New York whose life (and career) changes for the better when he meets a mysterious girl, Jennie Appleton (Jennifer Jones), by chance in Central   Park. Each time he meets her she appears older (growing miraculously from 12 to 20 in the space of a few months) and talks about people and events that happened in the 1920s.

What makes this film stand out is its side-stepping of all logic to immerse itself in a haunting, eerie and dream-like trance  which affects the viewer as much as it seems to affect Eben himself. Hitchock cited it as his prime inspiration for Vertigo, and it’s obvious in the almost narcotic mood of the film, but also in specific shots: the Brooklyn Bridge establishing shot, Eben’s studio echoing Midge’s, and Eben climbing the lighthouse steps at the end (I also think Scott Rosenberg made a Jennie reference in his script for Beautiful Girls when he had Natalie Portman’s Marty character flirting with the much older main character while ice skating… but that might just be me reading too much into it).

The premise of Portrait of Jennie is great, and the cinematography by Joseph August (who died immediately after   filming)    is absolutely stunning, with some drop dead gorgeous shots of Jennie emerging or disappearing through the New York mist against a backdrop of distant skyscrapers, and a soft focus film noir lighting that has faces almost totally obscured by shadow in many scenes.

Visually it is beautiful, but what destroys this film is the score, and the clunky, overbearing voice over. The latter is florid, obvious and, above all, on the nose, which could be due to adaptitis, with what sound like whole paragraphs cut and pasted into the script as voice over, explaining everything… and nothing.

But it’s Dmitri Tiomkin’s bloated, fussy and intrusive score that really undermines everything. Bernard Herrmann was apparently hired and then replaced early on, which strikes me as a tragic decision by Selznik, because Herrmann is exactly the kind of composer this film needs. My guess is he would have sent half the orchestra home and had the remainder working part time, such is his use of subtle orchestration used sparingly to great effect. Tiomkin, though, is a film composer of the old school: he never shuts up. His score plasters every scene and drowns out the dialogue in a desperate attempt to semaphore the meaning behind every line. Ten minutes in and you want to take out a gun and shoot the fucker just to get some peace.

And these are what make Portrait of Jennie an interesting failure and nowhere near the kind of film that should be in anyone’s Top Ten (well, maybe David O. Selznik’s). I guess realising what a mistake I made with it is a sign that in the last ten years I’ve become much more film literate and certainly more adept at spotting a bad script (or a script mangled by a producer, in this case). Or maybe it’s a sign of me getting older and responding to different storytelling stimuli. I know enough about my shifting tastes to know that I could probably recant every word here in another ten years.

But for now, there’s a vacancy in that Top Ten and I’m looking around for a replacement.


An early draft screenplay is available online. It is free of the achingly pretentious prologue and doesn’t have nearly as much voice over; a sure sign that it was added in post production at Selznik’s behest.

There are a few interesting reviews of Portrait of Jennie online, some containing screen caps:

Ravin’ Mavin’s fan site

Mondo Digital – Weird and Wild Cinema

GC Film Series

Jennifer Jones Filmography

Wikipedia

One of the landscape shots of New York from the film opens this review of the book Celluloid Skyline.