Unreliable witnesses

Last week I saw Atonement and left the cinema overwhelmed with the feeling  that I’d just witnessed a film that might  be a modern classic; a film that makes you realise you’ve been happily surviving on formulaic fast food and now you’ve had a taste of the gourmet.

I love the fact that it’s a British movie that dares to be unapologetically large scale. I love the fact that it plays narrative games and still manages to be moving. And I love the irony of a   heritage blockbuster that has the word ‘cunt’ as its major plot point.

I hadn’t seen Pride and Prejudice last year, so I knew nothing about director Joe Wright, though I remember chuckling at the trailers and thinking they’d made the mistake of filming an Austen novel as if it were a Bronte novel. It seemed far too dramatic for Austen’s acutely observed world of manners.

I guess many people who saw it  felt the same, because once I’d seen Atonement and started googling it, I was surprised to discover some venemous criticism of it. You know, the kind of criticism that seems a bit too vehement and out of place and has its roots in issues from long ago and makes the critic look like a bit of a tosser.

It’s symptomatic of a growing air of hyper-critical nonsense I’ve noticed everywhere I look these days. We live in the age of the laptop critic. In order to stand out in cyberspace you have to have an opinion. And negative opinion makes you sound more intelligent than positive opinion.

Negative opinion implies the kind of hidden intelligence and discernment that the slovenly pandering of positive opinion can only aspire to. If you want to appear intelligent, slag something off. Slag everything off. The more things you slag off, the more intelligent you will appear.

And some of the flak for Atonement on internet chat boards has been jaw-dropping in its pettiness.

According to the trolls, Atonement‘s Dunkirk scenes are ‘very unconvincing’, ‘the arrogance of the director overwhelms any tension or emotional impact’, and it all falls apart due to the ‘historical innacuracies on behalf of the director, e.g. a four-engined heavy bomber flying over England in 1935. The Dunkirk scenes were cringeworthy. Was there such strong anti-French sentiment expressed by English soldiers during the war? Questionable I’d say – more the fantasy of the director’. [All correct spelling and grammar are my own]

And so on and so forth.

Well, actually, anyone who’s studied real life accounts of the people who took part in that war (and I’ve got a shelf full of books devoted to the subject) will know that the movies of the 1950s (much as I love them) don’t really give us the true picture. The British Tommy was a far from politically correct beast. So I can quite imagine a bitter, retreating BEF squaddie slagging off the French. I’m only surprised he didn’t lay into the Jews as well, as a great many who wanted to avoid a war with Germany did at the time.

In that vein, I was particularly pleased with the stirring rendition of Fuck ’em all, which might sound anachronistic if you’re used to war movies starring Dirk Bogarde and Kenneth More but was a genuine infantry favourite of the time, as one old war veteran I once got pissed with was very fond of demonstrating at high volume. I’d always thought it was the bowdlerised version of George Formby’s ‘Bless em all’, but researching this article I’m pleased to discover that the adult version was the original.

As for the four-engined bomber flying over England in 1935, yes, it’s totally inaccurate, and I believe it’s totally deliberate. The clue is in the line about Briony being ‘an unreliable witness’.

Everything we see in  Atonement is the novel (Two Figures by a Fountain) that Briony is writing, and it contains all the historical inaccuracies a teenage girl would have committed to paper. Everything we see is her fictitious account of events, even the flashbacks to take in alternative viewpoints. Would she make the mistake of having her character gaze at an anachronistic bomber flying above? Yes, I believe she would. And that is the only reason that shot is in the film.

But it’s far too subtle a clue for the trolls, it would appear.

Having seen Atonement once, I couldn’t resist nipping back to the cinema a couple of days later to immerse myself in it again. For once, it looks like the film of the year might well be a British film. And that’s something to be proud of.

It’s a free download…

So here it is, the first of my shows from the Edinburgh International Film Festival, where I hooked up with screenwriter Paul Laverty to talk about his new film It’s A Free World and the past decade of writing screenplays with director Ken Loach.

I actually met Paul ten years ago when he came to Birmingham to do a Q&A for his first film, Carla’s Song. I was working at the Electric Cinema and grabbed the chance to be the hospitality guy who took Paul for a meal at the nearest restaurant while the film was showing. He was the first working screenwriter I’d ever talked to at length and we had a great conversation before I reluctantly took him back to the Electric for the end of the film.

He’s since written six more features with Ken Loach and his newest, It’s A Free World, wasn’t actually showing in Edinburgh (see humorous excerpt within the show) because it was premiering at the Venice Film Festival the week after. Paul was in Edinburgh for an In Person talk with festival director Hannah McGill that was absolutely packed to the rafters.

He talked about scenes from My Name is Joe, The Wind That Shakes the Barley, Sweet Sixteen and Bread and Roses, and the perils of writing politically committed cinema that’s about real characters and avoids the mere illustrating of issues.

I recorded the session and then re-introduced myself  as people piled out to ask him if he’d like to give an interview for the Shooting Screenwriters show. He was happy to but only had 10 minutes of his day free later that night before some meal he had to attend. So we hooked up later and he happily talked for half an hour before I let him go.


Paul on screenwriting courses : People seem to take great delight in knocking all these courses but I actually learned a great deal,  because I had so much to learn, and still do I think … finding out how other people do it is not a bad idea in any job, is it!

On working with Ken Loach : I suppose neither of us are great ones for the auteur theory. I’m a writer and he’s a director and we meet in the middle as filmmakers. 

On writing ‘issues’ : I don’t think a great issue makes for a great film. You have to find a subtle and unexpected way into it. But I think great issues deserve a great story.


The show  now has a svelte 30-mins-or-less time slot and you can either right-click and ‘Save target as’ to download it, or go to the Shooting People Podcasts page to subscribe for free and get future shows sent to you direct.

It’s A Free World won the Best Screenplay prize at Venice the following week and it’s being screened by Channel 4 within the next fortnight with a DVD release in October.

Camping it up

So anyway, I spent a large part of last weekend at the Podcamp UK (un)Conference in Birmingham  where podcasters from   all over Europe came together to talk all manner of things to do with podcasting.

As with most things I attempt, my podcasting has involved me running blindly into a darkened room without turning the lights on and then attempting to cook an omelette, only later to find out I’m in the bathroom, not the kitchen.

In short, I tend to screw the manual and try to wing it on instinct. Which pretty much explains the wildly varying sound quality on offer at my Shooting People podcast.

The first thing that hit me was, this was not like any other conference I’d been to (which is why they call it an unconference, I suppose). From the outset it seemed chaotic and disorganised. People were invited to make up the programme for the day and while delegates came to the front and announced what they’d like to learn about, other delegates, and organisers, were talking amongst themselves.

Now this is one of my pet hates. I was the guy at uni whose eyed rolled over in their sockets if you whispered something to me while the lecturer was talking. I don’t like it. It’s fucking rude.

Not only were people talking amongst themselves, half the audience were tapping away at laptops.

Now, I think when it comes to living one’s life online, I leave most of my friends in the Bronze Age. Most of the people I know aren’t even on MSN. One guy doesn’t even have an email address. But this PodCamp lot made me  feel like I was wearing a smoking jacket and spats. These were people whose laptops were literally an extension of their bodies and they talked about metrics, and white labelling and friendship inflation and, er… poking. And none of them mean what I thought they meant.

Is there anything more intrinsically ironic than a round table discussion about Social Networking when half of the people in the discussion are surfing on their laptops? (Answers in an instant message, please).

So for the first few hours I felt old in a way I have never felt before.  But then I decided it was a learning curve and I should start learning. I was in a room full of professionals who could teach me not only the basics but also give me tips for taking it all to the next level.

Paul Parkinson of Podcast User Magazine gave an excellent Audio 101 lecture, in which I discovered exactly how to sort out my sound issues and make the podcast more listenable (the main problem was all down to Audacity’s aptly named LAME encoder, which should be avoided at all costs. The clue was in the name, I suppose).

And throughout the other sessions I had new thoughts about changing the format and the possibility of marketing it and maybe making it pay for itself.

The strangest fact that came up was that the Chris Moyles podcast recently doubled its listeners after changing its name from a ‘podcast’ to a ‘free download’. So it’s obvious that the vast majority of people out there still don’t know what a podcast is (clue: it’s just a free download) and are frightened by the word.

I learned a hell of a lot, and the Shooting People podcasts, sorry, free downloads, will be changing   as a result, but the other great thing about the weekend was that Jurgen Wolff was in attendance (he’d told me about it, in fact) and we managed to interview each other for   our respective podcasts (how utterly postmodern, said my flatmate).

So I will be making a guest appearance on his, talking about how brilliant   Shooting People is, and he’ll be the subject of a forthcoming Shooters podcast   talking about his new book Your Writing Coach and his superb creativity   exercises.

I have to give a big thank you to the Podcamp UK organisers for providing   such a brilliant and totally FREE conference for everyone. I made some great   contacts and learned so much, and I’ll definitely be attending the next one.

I think all of the sessions were filmed and you can view them here.

The quality isn’t that great but you get a feel for the event and might learn   some interesting things.

Edinburgh 2007

After the unbelievable hassle of vlogging from the Cheltenham Screenwriters’ Festival, I vowed that the next one would be a nice, easy written blog. And as if by magic, the Edinburgh International Film Festival announced that its theme for 2007 would be ‘cinema and the written word’.

So I set off to spend five days there, see lots of films, meet new and interesting people, and get it all down on my laptop as it happened.

I’d   had no intention of going to this festival initially as I couldn’t see that it would be any use to a screenwriter. But I caved in to persuasion from others far more knowledgeable than me and decided to go for it.

On the networking front, it wasn’t as easy as Cheltenham. There you knew that you could talk to anyone because they were either a screenwriter themselves    or they were there to meet screenwriters. In Edinburgh it’s very different and half of the people you end up talking to are little use to your career as a screenwriter.

Perhaps it might have been different if the ‘written word’ theme of the festival had delivered in any meaningful way, but that was very disappointing.

Writers know way too much about the industry and their place within it these days to be grateful for a handful of writer-director In Person sessions. That doesn’t constitute a theme. It constitutes a token gesture, and not a very convincing one at that. There were no more writer-centric events than you’d expect at any film festival.

On the whole, though, I had a positive experience. I met a lot of interesting people and saw a lot of good films, films that gave me some much needed impetus to write and sort out my own scripts.

In the end, I suppose, just being around filmmakers and films is enough for a screenwriter.

Now it’s back to those screenplays of my own…


The blog is published on the  new Festival Focus page of Shooting People’s website, and this is what I wrote about :

Yeah,   boyeeee (and shit)
I touchdown and go on a mad search for a movie fix and end up with a film about breakdancing.

You can’t fool the children of the revolution
Hungarian film about the 56 revolution, Szabadsag, Szerelem (Children of Glory), falls a bit flat, even with a magyarphile like me.

It’s a dirty job but someone’s gotta do it…
Torture porn thriller WΔZjust wasn’t, but a big party night made up for it.

And when did you last cry in a cinema?
Another Hungarian film, Kythéra, and the powerful And When Did You Last See Your Father?

Spiegel im spiegel
A night out on the town with some new friends, with shocking photographic evidence.

Sweet and deadly
UK urban thriller, Sugarhouse takes me by surprise.

Meetings with Scottish screenwriters
In which your intrepid reporter interviews Paul Laverty and hangs out with the Scottish Screenwriters group.

And the special prize goes to…
Justin Edgar’s new film, Special People, is really rather good.

The waiting is the best bit…
I go down to the basement Videotheque and watch the nice new Brit romance, The Waiting Room. It’s obviously feelgood day.

Crazy in love
Sisterly rivalry in German film Schwesterherz (Twisted Sister) and Julie Delpy being totally bonkers in her brilliant new comedy Two Days in Paris.

See you all next June
Yes, they’re taking it away from the main festival and plonking it in June, all on its own, next year.

Wouldn’t you just die without Mahler…

For once, I’m not writing about writing. A couple of things that happened over the last fortnight have made me want to write about that most perilously indefinable subject: music. And classical music at that.

First off, I experienced a sudden reawakening of my desire to spend some time with Gustav Mahler, a composer whose universe I’ve inhabited, off and on, for the last 25 years.

You’ve all done the same: you suddenly get a taste for a certain album or artist out of the blue, and only they will do, and you blow the dust off that old album and play it on a loop for a fortnight and then just as suddenly file it back (alphabetically, if you’re male), not to grace your eardrums for another year or two.

Well this fortnight it’s been Mahler and most of his symphonies for me.

Secondly, I noticed a big feature in the Observer by a former rock journalist espousing his new found love of classical music. I always hate those things (you’ll see why in a minute), but I gave it a read and yes, it was one of those disappointing experiences where you find yourself shouting ‘What!? We did all that yonks ago! Come on! Catch up!’

Now, I grew up reading Sean O’Hagan in the NME and I have nothing but respect for him, and the way he talks about only finding meaning in music through the classical route following the death  of his brother is genuinely moving.

It’s just that I’ve never understood this view that classical music is something you mature into and can only appreciate once your first grey hairs start sprouting.

As a working-class kid, growing up on the streets of Rochdale and then Birmingham, there wasn’t much in the way of classical music. No one listened to it. Our school in Rochdale did have an orchestra but the classical repertoire was a little bit beyond them. So the only experience you had of it was through movies.

But I remember at the age of 11 announcing that I liked Strauss’s Blue Danube waltz when I heard it on 2001: A Space Odyssey. Even at that age I obviously enjoyed going against the grain and standing out from the crowd by liking stuff that no one else would say they liked (a pattern that continued throughout my adult life).

But it was as a teenager that I first started seriously listening to classical music. Like most of the teenagers I knew back then I was an avid member of the ‘alternative’ scene: I knew all the words to Joy Division songs, listened to John Peel every night, had a second-hand overcoat three sizes too big, and showed my musical maturity by delving into old bands like The Doors and the Jimi Hendrix Experience.

Then Richard Jobson got me into the films (and books) of Dirk Bogarde and Death in Venice got me into Mahler. I remember the first time I walked up to the Birmingham Central Library’s third floor music library and nervously looked through the classical section hoping no one I knew would see me.

I took out Mahler’s fifth symphony and, sure enough, bumped into one of my (much cooler than me) ‘alternative’ mates. When he asked me what record I’d got out and I stammered the response he just shrugged and said ‘Oh yeah, Mahler. Wicked.’ I took it home grinning to myself. Mahler was cool.

So I spent my teenage years listening to symphonies as well as three-minute songs (actually five minutes was the average for ‘alternative’ bands). I bought the complete Marshall Cavendish Great Composers partworks set and discovered Beethoven and Bach and the beauty of baroque.

I even got my working class family to appreciate it and, in no time at all, we all thought nothing of having Mahler’s Fifth on in the house. (This was a big thing for a kid from Kirkholt, Rochdale, believe me).

That’s why I don’t get this whole classical music as some kind of bar mitzvah  for fortysomethings. It has always existed side by side with rock and pop for me. Mozart with Madonna, Bach with Bowie, Prokofiev with the Pogues.

Which is a roundabout way of saying there are only two kinds of music:  music that moves something inside you and music that doesn’t.


Bach to Basics : a few suggestions for the classical virgin

Gustav Mahler’s symphonies
Forget Sean O’Hagan’s suggestion of Tchaikovsky’s symphonies. Mawkish meaningless scales rushing up and down. They suck big time. Mahler is where it’s at. No other composer speaks to our modern condition of knee-jerk irony and tragedy sitting side by side with comedy. These are the best ones to try out:
Symphony no 1: Full of infectious, youthful joy (and a child’s funeral march. It’s what he does).
Symphony no 4: Simple. child-like, innocent, but of course with a few shadows cast.
Symphony no 5: Monumental, epic struggle that emerges from despair to end in a blaze of glory.
Symphony no 6: His only truly ‘tragic’ symphony. Brutal, cruel, sardonic but strangely energising and ironically contains his most beautiful slow movement.
Symphony no 9: A constant wrestling with despair that ends in calm repose.
Symphony no 10: His unfinished (but in my mind has greater validity as a finished item than, say, Mozart’s Requiem) and my own favourite. More utter despair, of course, but the final movement is one of the most beautiful expressions of love in music ever written.

Arvo Pärt’s Tabula Rasa and Henryk Górecki’s Symphony no 3: Symphony of Sorrowful Songs
O’Hagan is bang on with these two. I listened to them both pretty much constantly throughout my uni years (where I also discovered Tom Waits). From the modern school of ‘holy minimalism’. Tabula Rasa is a stunning piece for two violins and ‘prepared’ piano. Górecki’s Symphony of Sorrowful Songs takes Polish poems about the Holocaust and sets them them to divinely simple canons. It became my mother’s favourite CD and the piece of music I buried her to last year.

JS Bach’s The Well Tempered Clavier
Beautiful and serene piano configurations that represent some of the greatest architecture in human history.

Mozart’s late piano concertos 14-27
Written at a time when court ‘servants’ like Mozart were starting to realise they were the movers and shakers, not their masters, the counterpoint of piano and orchestra represents the relationship of the individual and society. The emphasis may be on the individual, but the theme is still unity. When I listen to these everything seems right with the world.

Carl Orff’s Carmina Burana
Everyone knows this. A high energy romp through a set of medieaval songs that’s as exhilerating as any rock band. And it’s all about a group of monks trying to break into a convent to shag the nuns… apparently.

Ralph Vaughan Williams’ symphonies
The greatest of the English composers who composed a series of amazing symphonies: the second (London) evokes the sounds of a modern city, the third (Pastoral) explores the landscape of the Somme, the fifth is a beautiful meditation on nature, but it’s the war-like fourth and sixth that really kick it. Stunning. His almost-a-symphony, Job: A Masque for Dancing, is Vaughan Williams in miniature. It’s all there: the soaring pastoral anthems, the catchy folk dances, the sublime slow movements, the outbursts of brutality. A great piece of music.

Dallapiccola’s Tartiniana Seconda
A rarity by a modern composer whose output is largely on the atonal side. But this is a lovely suite for piano and violin full of life and wit and warmth. (Tracks 24-27 on the link).


Sean O’Hagan’s article From Iggy to Gigli: my journey to the Proms is available on the Observer website.

The great British screenplay…

A little while ago on the Screenwriters’ bulletin we tried to come up with a list of British screenplays worth studying for budding UK screenwriters.

I could name a hundred British movies with great scripts but I’ve tried to   concentrate on ones where a draft screenplay is actually available for study. This means I can’t really mention a favourite of mine: Michael Eaton’s Fellow Traveller, which you can’t get anywhere, nor Peter Chelsom and Adrian Dunbar’s screenplay for Hear My Song, or Peter Howitt’s Sliding Doors, all three of which are strong genre-bending scripts that I love, not to mention Patrick Marber’s brilliant Closer.

There are also UK-set scripts by US writers, and vice-versa, that I was going to avoid, but there’s an argument for the former if what you want to know is   how to write credible UK-set screenplays.

When I list them like this it becomes clear to me that what I’m seeking in British screenwriting is an escape from depressing social realism. I never knew.

So here goes. These are the ones that do it for me.

(You might want to right-click on the ‘Download’ options and ‘Save target as’ if you want to download it rather than read it online).

The Singing Detective
[Dennis Potter]. Yes it’s a near-seven hour TV serial   and if you buy the paperback it’s not even laid out properly (no sluglines,   etc), so don’t go to this one for anything but the poetry. The most beautifully   written script I’ve ever read and the one I get off the shelf when I need to   feel inspired and be reminded that screenwriting is an art as well as a craft   and can (and should) be a beautiful read. Buy it now.

Four Weddings and a Funeral
[Richard Curtis]. It’s fashionable to hate this   but say what you like, it took a US genre staple and made a   convincing Brit version of it that sold all over the world. It’s great screenwriting, pure and simple, and anyone who moans about it being unrealistic can do one as far as I’m concerned. [Buy it]

Shallow Grave / Trainspotting
[John Hodge]. Two great group-in-peril thrillers, of a sort. They remind me that we can do gritty, modern and cool as fuck as well as any Americans, and that we don’t have to be so grim up north. [Download / Download]

Shakespeare in Love
[Marc Norman & Tom Stoppard]. Yes, Marc Norman is a yank, but everything else about this is quintessentially English (apart from the Hollywood in-jokes). It’s about a young Shakespeare… as an up and coming (screen)writer… it’s romantic… and funny… and literate… and there’s a bit with a dog. [Download]

The Life & Death of Colonel Blimp
[Emeric Pressburger] A much overlooked screenwriter. Only a Hungarian emigre could write so many brilliant scripts about what it really means to be British, and this is just one of many. Pure gold from start to finish. [Download]

Withnail & I
[Bruce Robinson] Not just for the quote-on-every-page comedy of it but also because it’s a very touching portrait of outgrowing friends you thought you’d never outgrow. [Download]

Possession
[Laura Jones and Neil LaBute] Another one that’s written by yanks but an adaptation of an English novel, set in England and managing to have its modern cake while, er, eating its heritage (or something). The script that’s available online, written by David Henry Hwang, is obviously an early draft. What later emerged by Jones and LaBute is markedly different and much more appealing in my view. [Download]

Now do you get it?

So anyway, I’ve been catching up on some  early Seinfeld  courtesy of the miracle of DVD box sets, and  pontificating on how there are two kinds of people in this crazy, mixed up world. There are those who get Seinfeld, and there are those who don’t. And those who don’t get it, I realise with increasing frequency, are people I will never fully trust.

I caught on to Seinfeld late, thanks to the BBC’s typical foresight and sensitivity in buying this masterpiece and screening it in some graveyard slot on BBC2 round about midnight, instead of in the prime time slot it deserved. The BBC never did understand what a cult hit they had. They just didn’t get it.  So it wasn’t until the middle of season 5when I happened upon it.

I was expecting the usual American sitcom fare, but something about this was different and I couldn’t put my finger on it. It had this walking slapstick guy called Kramer in it and he bought a cigar store Indian on a whim, even though it was a terribly politically incorrect thing to do. I’d just come through a decade of po-faced PC bullshit, so at a deep level I needed something that was this irreverent.

I made a point of catching it again and pretty soon I was watching an episode where eternal loser George Costanza pretends to be a marine biologist to impress a date, a lie that backfires spectacularly when he has to rescue a beached whale. The moment he related the story to the others in the diner and said ‘The sea was angry that day, my friends..’ That was the moment I was hooked.

I raved about the show to my best mates. They watched an episode. They didn’t get it. I was deeply disappointed. They tried a few more and then got hooked just like I had. (Phew! That was almost twenty years of friendship down the toilet).

Over the years I’ve given people the Seinfeld test, just to check they’re the kind of person I’d like to hang out with.  New girlfriends especially. If a girl lets slip she’s a Seinfeld fan before I’ve even mentioned it, she’s a keeper. If I hear a guy rave about it, I know he’s someone I can have a laugh with.

The people who just don’t get it… I’m sorry, there’ll always be something between us.

This may sound absurd, and rather too imitative of characters who dump their lovers on the flimsiest of pretexts (inappropriate use of exclamation marks, having man hands, dressing like a communist) but if you don’t get Seinfeld, you don’t get something crucial about irony in the modern world, and let’s face it, you probably take life too seriously.

I know people who love Curb Your Enthusiasm but hate Seinfeld. The former they see as cutting edge and radical, the latter as tame and traditional. They just don’t get it.

It’s obvious that many people mistake Seinfeld for a traditional sitcom. It’s true, it’s recorded before a live audience, looks glossy, looks like so many other sitcoms that came before it and many that followed in its wake (yes, that’s you, Frasier, and you, Friends). But to view it as in any way similar to those shows is to fundamentally misunderstand what Seinfeld is really all about.

Watching the early seasons on DVD, it strikes me just how much Seinfeld broke the mould. There were a few years early on when it was just a tiny little cult show about a few disenchanted New Yorkers, where nothing ever happened and they talked about the trivialities of everyday life (and also when episodes seemed to just fizzle out because the characters had run out of things to say – not because any kind of resolution had been reached).

Only with season 4, the breakthrough season, did it suddenly cross over and make it big. Maybe it was because the plotting became tighter and each show involved four throughlines that would be resolved neatly with a twist that brought them all together at the end. Or maybe it was because of a certain episode where the heroes had a contest to see who could refrain from wanking the longest.

Can you imagine Friends doing that? No, me neither. Seinfeld not only dared to tackle issues that no other sitcom would go near, it also flouted the golden rule of Hollywood storytelling with its militant ‘no hugs, no lessons’ rule.

Another reason  people don’t get it is Jerry Seinfeld himself. They mistake the show for an absurd vanity project in which this big-toothed, big haired, white trainer-wearing smug comedian plays himself as ultra-cool ladykiller dispensing bon-mots by the minute.

It’s true that some Seinfeld storylines derive their comedy from Jerry doing something successful, usually in contrast to Elaine, George or Kramer suffering the flip side. But these are much rarer than the moments where Jerry is the fall guy.

The ‘Jerry’ of the series is, in fact, the much less successful man that the real world Jerry might have become if his NBC pilot had been cancelled. Bizarro Jerry, if you will. This ‘Jerry’ is a small time stand-up whose success in life is so modest that all of his friends casually dismiss any pretensions he has to working in ‘show business’. Whose parents still want him to get a proper job and won’t let him pay for anything. Who gets ‘bumped’ continually when trying to get the ‘gig’ of addressing his old school assembly. He is, in short, regularly the butt of the show’s cruel, merciless deflating of pomposity.

Are you starting to see where the idea for Curb Your Enthusiasmcame from?

Were it not for Seinfeld blazing the trail in mentioning the unmentionable, deflating pretension and resolutely resisting resolution we wouldn’t have cult comedy like Curb, or The Gary Shandling Show, or Spaced, or The Office.

As Greg M Smith pointed out in his seminal essay, Plotting a Show About Nothing, ‘while Hollywood storytelling tends to confirm the “work hard and you’ll achieve your dreams” myth by repeatedly showing protagonists successfully laboring to achieve their goals Seinfeld turns this central myth of American capitalism on its ear. In this show, working to achieve desires has little to do with whether or not characters actually attain these desires. Usually the outcome is based on factors outside their control. And if they do happen to get what they want, they discover that this is not what they wanted at all.’

The more I watch it, the more I realise I like it because it speaks to something profoundly philosophical in me that has never wanted to grow up, that has always been sceptical about      what other people regard as important, that sits in the coffee shop of life watching the real world rush by, making smart arse remarks and debating the excruciating minutiae of nothing and everything.

As Stuart Jeffries put it in Mrs Slocombe’s Pussy, his meditation on a lifetime’s TV viewing, ‘this, I realised, was mostly what I wanted from American TV – decadent, immature lives performed on TV for my pleasure.’

The Seinfeld universe is  about accepting that we live in a world where people are rewarded or punished randomly, through no effort of their own; where achieving your goal immediately results in you no longer wanting that goal and having to work hard to get out of it; where actions taken on a whim can have catastrophic consequences.

And if you think life is more than that, you really don’t get it.


15 Seinfeld episodes you must see before you die

The Deal | Season 2
Jerry  and Elaine devise an elaborate system wherein they can be both friends and  lovers. Features a superb  extended opener with Jerry and Elaine negotiating their fuck buddy status.

George : That’s why I   don’t have cable in my house. Because of that naked station. If I had that in my   house, I would never turn it off. I wouldn’t sleep, I wouldn’t eat. Eventually,   firemen would have to break through the door. They’d find me sitting there in my   pyjamas with drool coming down my face.

The Pitch | Season 4
Jerry  and George pitch a ‘show about nothing’ to NBC.

Jerry (to George) : You really need some help. A regular psychiatrist couldn’t even help you. You   need to go to, like, Vienna or something.

The  Contest | Season 4
Jerry,  George, Kramer and Elaine bet on who can wait longer to… ‘you know’.

Mrs Costanza : I go out to get some milk, I come home and I find my son treating his body as if   it was an amusement park!

The Outing | Season 4
An  NYU journalist thinks that Jerry and George are gay. Not that there’s anything wrong with  that…

George : You can do better than me. You could throw a dart out the window and hit someone  better than me. I’m no good!

The  Marine Biologist | Season 5
George  has to pretend to be a marine biologist to impress a woman. “The sea  was angry that day, my friends…”

Jerry : He’s working on lowering the cholesterol level in whales. All that blubber, it’s quite unhealthy. You know, it’s the largest mammal on earth. But as George says, they don’t have to be.

The  Soup Nazi | Season 7
Elaine falls out with the Soup Nazi. One of those where all four storylines are perfect. I’ve  actually been served by the real Soup Nazi, you know. “I gotta sit down…”

George : Why can’t we share?
Jerry : I told you not to say anything. You can’t go in there, brazenly flout the rules and then think I’m gonna share with you.
George : Do you hear yourself?
Jerry : I’m sorry. This is what comes from living under a Nazi regime!

The Sponge | Season 7
Elaine runs out of contraceptive sponges. Jerry dates an AIDS charity worker.

Jerry : You  can’t have sex with someone you admire!

The Invitations | Season 7
Susan dies from toxic glue on the cheap wedding invitations that George insisted on. Jerry falls in love with guest star Janeane Garofalo, after discovering she is just  like him.

Jerry : All this time, I’ve  been waiting for me to come along, and now I’ve swept myself off my feet!

The Bizarro Jerry | Season 8
Elaine  finds friends who are the exact opposites of Jerry, George, and Kramer. Kramer  gets an office job. George dates a model and tastes life in the ‘forbidden  city’. Jerry dates a girl with ‘man hands’. One of those episodes that fires on all four cylinders. The George storyline is particularly sublime.

Elaine : I can’t spend the  rest of my life coming into this stinking apartment every ten minutes to pore  over the excruciating minutiae of every single daily event!

The Abstinence | Season 8
George gets smart when he stops having  sex, but it has the opposite effect on Elaine. Jerry gets bumped at a junior  high assembly gig. Kramer starts a smoking club.

George : I always knew that, once I became a doctor, I would dump  whoever I was with and find someone better. That’s the dream of becoming a  doctor.

The Yada Yada | Season 8
George dates a very succinct girl.  Jerry’s dentist becomes a Jew for the jokes. Perhaps  my all time fave Seinfeld episode. Four amazing plotlines that intertwine with  dazzling panache. A thing of beauty, scriptwise, and a killer of a twist at the  end.

Jerry : I wanted to talk to you about Dr. Whatley. I have a suspicion that he’s   converted to Judaism purely for the jokes.
Father Curtis : And this offends you as a Jewish person?
Jerry : No. It offends me as a comedian!

The Voice | Season 9
Jerry can’t decide which he  likes better: his girlfriend or the funny voice that drives her crazy. I  like this one because we’ve all, at one time or another, had to  choose between a girl and a joke about her stomach speaking in a funny voice.

Jerry : Breaking up is like knocking over a Coke machine. You can’t do it in one push. You gotta rock it back and forth a few times, and then it goes over.

The Merv Griffin Show | Season 9
Kramer finds the old Merv  Griffin Show set and reconstructs it at home, where he proceeds to ‘interview’ everyone who calls by.

Kramer : Wait a minute. You mean to say that you drugged a woman so you could take advantage of her toys?

The Betrayal | Season 9
The Emmy-winning backwards episode, which  shows the ultimate mastery of the Seinfeld scriptwriters. How many other sitcom episodes are inspired by Harold Pinter?

Jerry: Well, everybody’s a little cranky on their birthday.
George: Oh, it’s a bad day. You got everyone in your house,   you’re thinkin’, “These are my friends?!”
Jerry: Every day is my birthday.

The  Dealership | Season 9
Jerry tries to get an  insider deal on a new car from David Putty.

Jerry : He keeps asking me to give him a high-five.
Elaine : I thought all guys do that.
Jerry : Slapping hands is the lowest form of primate ritual.

Steps back in amazement…

I made a really big breakthrough the other night with Players, the TV pilot about seduction artists I’m writing.   I’d thought it was ready to go until we picked at a little thread   and the whole thing came apart.  

So there I was, building a whole new story on   the foundations of the first (I’m mixing the weaving and building metaphors  here, I know. Just go with it).

But what saved me was going back to the age old method: writing out the major   scenes on index cards. And not only that, but writing in big black felt tip, so  there was no space for lots of distracting detail – just the broad headlines,   and not even scenes but sequences.

I haven’t done this in ages because I’m a bit of a tech freak and I like to   do everything on my 15″ widescreen laptop, so I’ve been using the index card   view in Final Draft to lay out my plots.

But that’s too awkward. Final Draft only recognises scenes in its index card   view. That means everything with a slugline has its own card. What it really   needs is a function where you can group several scenes together as a sequence.   And then you need an option to give sequences or scenes a title that you can   choose to view or not, so that when you’re playing around in the index card view   you can be looking at things like “HARRY GETS MEDIEAVAL ON LARRY’S ASS!” instead   of “INT. BOXING RING – NIGHT”. Then the index card view would be more like the   real thing.

But Final Draft doesn’t have that function (as far as I know, and believe me   I’ve looked for it) so it was back to real card and black marker.

When I talked about this on the Shooters bulletin, a few screenwriters responded with programmes they’d tried out.

Ian Black threw up Mindmanager 6 from Mindjet: ‘It’s  Mind Mapping software and allows the development of map threads which can   have files attached if desired. There are options for various views as suited   and maps can be exported to other software e.g. Word, Outlook (as tasks), but   not Final Draft.’

Alan O’Leary recommended ‘Storylines’, which is part of the Writers Cafe suite: ‘Most of the suite is kinda useless – note-takers and the   like – but storyliner lets you set up through-lines, plot cards on them, then   drag and drop them around. Then you can export into text document (see this screenshot).’

But John Killeen seems to have come closest with this SuperNotecard for Scriptwriting,  which I notice claims to ‘export seamlessly’ to Final Draft.

All of these are useful, but not quite what I need. The people at Final Draft and/or Movie Magic Screenwriter need to sort out their index card view and really making it useful to working screenwriters. Until that time it’s real cards, a black marker and a cork board.

It was gratifying to know, though, that when you think you’ve totally lost   it, you can always get it back again by taking a big step backwards (away from   the laptop) and trying to see the big picture.