Dramatica: the DNA of story?

NEWSFLASH. Since writing this article I’ve since had the pleasure of interviewing Dramatica co-creator, Chris Huntley for the Shooting Screenwriters podcast, in which we discussed all things Dramatica for an enterataining and highly illuminating 40 minutes. See here.   

Imagine you turn on the news and hear that  a couple of scientists have discovered the DNA of story: that each story,  whether it be a novel, a screenplay, a sitcom script or a Simpsons episode, can  be reduced to a precise sequence of elements, and that that secret formula has  finally been uncovered.

For some writers it’s an horrific thought.  Despite centuries of structural analysis (kicked off by Aristotle) to uncover the  mystery of what it is that makes us feel that very special feeling we get when  we’re experiencing a story, some writers would still have us believe that the  recipe for a great story requires equal measures of blood, sweat and tears, garnished  with a side order of genius. Well, yes, as a writer I’m duty-bound to say it  involves all those things, but none of them explain why most beginners’  screenplays sag in the middle, or why a lot of novels entertain but fail to  move in the way that, say, To Kill a  Mockingbird moves, or feel just right, in the way that works as  diverse as Casablanca, When Harry Met Sally, Boyz N the Hood and Hamlet feel right.

Eureka!

Well, two ‘scientists’ might have uncovered  this DNA of story, but it won’t be on the news because it happened 12 years  ago. Melanie Anne Phillips and Chris Huntley set out to write an instruction  manual for screenwriters in 1981 but, ten years later, ended up with a brave  new theory of fiction reduced to a four-tier cube that looks like ‘a Vulcan  crossword puzzle’.

Imagine a matrix of 340 story components, each  one a concept represented by a single word or phrase. Your story plots a path  through this matrix, touching on 84 different appreciations. This means there  are 32,768 different combinations to try out.

May the Force be with you

To give the broad sweep of the theory, a  fully-formed story can be divided into four separate throughlines, each with  its own concerns, issues and problems. There’s a throughline for the main  character, another one for the ‘impact’ (or obstacle) character, a separate  throughline that explores the struggle between these two characters, and  finally the overall story throughline, which maps out the concerns and themes  of the story as a whole.

These four throughlines always fall into  the four main domains of

  • a Situation
  • a Fixed Attitude
  • a Manner of  Thinking/Psychological Manipulation
  • and an Activity

Take Star Wars as an example. The Main Character throughline is Luke  Skywalker’s and he’s trapped in a Situation (can he ever get off this crumby  planet where nothing ever happens and make a name for himself?). Then there’s  the Impact Character, Obi-Wan Kenobi, who represents a Fixed Attitude (in order  to be one with the Force you have to let go of yourself). The third throughline  is about the Manipulations between these two (Obi-Wan wants Luke to be a  faithful student but Luke just wants adventure). The Overall throughline of  Activity is about the battle between the Rebels and the Empire, which all the characters  are caught up in.

You can reduce any grand argument story to  these four domains. Take Titanic. There,  the Main Character is Rose, and her throughline is Psychological Manipulations  (she’s trying to be an independent woman instead of her future husband’s  property); Jack is her Impact Character and he’s involved in the Activity of  ‘obtaining’ (a passage home and an engaged woman’s love); the struggle between  them takes place in the Situation domain, which is perhaps best illustrated by  the bars of a cage (they want to escape to a future together but they’re  trapped by society’s conventions, and on a sinking ship), and in the Overall  Story, we see a Fixed Attitude (‘God himself could not sink this ship’, so  where’s all the water coming from?).

But doesn’t this all lead to formulaic  stories? Well, with 32,768 possible combinations, the answer is no, and, in the  end, it’s how you illustrate all those appreciations that really matters.

Breaking it down

This only scratches the shiny surface of  Dramatica theory, though. Each throughline contains a wealth of elements to be  explored and it can be a pretty complex process dealing with them all.

Attempts to make the theory more accessible  are now well under way. Not only is Dramatica available as a computer programme  that automates your choices, but there’s a theory book (free online), a website  full of handy tips, an email discussion group used by writers from all over the  world, an audio course (free online) and now the work of Armando Saldana Mora,  an early disciple of the theory who first developed ‘Instant Dramatica’ (an  approach that can get your story up and running in no time) and is now  publishing Dramatica for Screenwriters in serial form (available free on the  website), and will follow it with Dramatica for Novelists.

The best starting point, though, is the  excellent comic book (downloadable as a pdf file), which gives the broad  picture in an accessible and entertaining style (i.e. for idiots like me).

A degree in the art of story

But, in the end, writing stories isn’t an  easy business. Dramatica theory is a very steep learning curve, no doubt about  it, and it could take you a year to master, but think of it as a degree in the  art of story, and then marvel as it breathes new life into that old screenplay  gathering dust because it’s still not quite there, or fills the gaps in that  novel that never quite felt right.

If you’re serious about yourself as a  writer of fiction, can you afford to be without it?

 

Links:

Dramatica   software programme

Dramatica   website

Jim Hull’s Daily Dramatica blog

Dramatica User’s Group monthly podcast

Theory book (free online)

Dramatica for Screenwriters

Comic book (right click and ‘Save as’ to download)

How I learned to stop worrying and get a writing partner

There are two kinds of writer: those who  treat their work in progress with the obsessive secrecy of a Freemason member  of the Magic Circle  who sidelines as a government spy, and those who can quite easily badger startled  strangers in a coffee shop for opinions on the line they’ve just scribbled on a  napkin.

Continue reading →

Hello, do you have a tax shelter?

How wannabe film producers get their training with EAVE

Dentists, lawyers and electricians can all  go to college to be trained in their job. In the film world you can even go to  directing school or a writing academy. But no one teaches you how to be a film  producer. It’s just something you learn to do when you balls it up as a  director, isn’t it?

Okay, that’s a joke, but the point remains  that you can do film school if you want to direct, or take any one of the  Writing MAs that have sprung up around the country if you want to be a  scriptwriter; but what do you do if you want to be a producer?

Well, the answer is, you go to EAVE, and,  to my surprise, that’s been the tried and tested route for over a decade now.  EAVE (pronounced ‘Ee-ah-vay’), in fact, seems to be the European film  industry’s best kept secret, having not only developed a great many European  films over the years, but also trained most of Europe’s film producers.  Suddenly, having attended one of their workshops for a week, I find that most  of the producers I meet are EAVE graduates. It’s like discovering some secret  brotherhood like the Masons or the Rosicrucians. They’re everywhere.

Committing to EAVE means taking three  week-long workshops over the space of a year, each one in a different European  city. The first workshop will be concerned with Development and most producers  go with a scriptwriter to kick a project into shape. The second workshop will  train participants in Packaging and Finance. Finally, the third workshop is a  monster pitching session where you get to try and sell your project to scores  of top producers.

It’s not just three weeks’ work, though. In  between workshops you’ll be developing your project whilst liaising with your  group leader and specialist experts. EAVE also means accepting that you will  spend a whole year on the film festival circuit. So you’re pretty much  committed to spending twelve months of your life schmoozing with the  cigar-chomping top brass of Eurofilm Incorporated.

It’s a hefty commitment to make, but the  effect is clear for anyone to see. This year EAVE came to Birmingham for the  first time, with the third workshop of the 2003 course, so I got an insight  into just how valuable an experience it can be.

First off, I’m a screenwriter, so it’s  interesting for me to see the producer’s angle on things. Secondly, my God –  look how many of them there are! For a whole week I’m surrounded by up to sixty  movie producers. It’s more producers than I’ve seen in my life so far. Do I  have enough business cards with me?

It’s not just that I’m hob-nobbing with the  next generation of continental movie producers; it’s also that a few of the  current generation of quite famous movie producers are here as well. I do a bit  of a double take when I find myself standing on the terrace of Ipanema and  realise that the lanky, slightly frayed at the edges guy I’m chatting to is  actually Nik Powell. You know, the guy who set up Virgin with Branson, then  went on to exec produce films like Company  of Wolves, Letter to Brezhnev, Mona Lisa, Scandal, Waterland, The Crying Game,  Backbeat, Fever Pitch and Little  Voice. Yeah, that Nik Powell.

But that kind of schmooze coup is par for  the course. A year on EAVE and you’ll have met nearly everyone who’s anyone on  the European film scene.

Mark Pressdee is finding that out. He’s  spent the past few years working on nearly every low/no-budget short film  production in the West Midlands and, consequently, has one of the most sought  after filofaxes in the local film industry. He already spends a large part of  his day fielding calls from frantic local line-producers who desperately need  runners, DOPs or lighting crews for the short they’re shooting, especially when  it’s First Cut or Digital Shorts time. But now he’s decided to become a bona  fide producer and has gone through the EAVE mill, emerging with an exhausted  look and a graduation certificate for his production office wall.

“It’s totally changed me,” says Mark. “This  year I’ve been to every film festival in Europe except, ironically, Edinburgh,  I’ve pitched my project idea in Cannes, I’ve just spent a week here in  Birmingham pitching to some of the biggest producers in Europe and some of them  are interested in the feature I’ve got. It’s the kind of experience that  changes you totally as a person. I actually feel like a film producer now. For  a giggle I even made the odd appearance in a suit and with a cigar! Seriously,  though, it filled me with self-believe. I now know I can push my projects. I  now believe in my talent as a producer to develop and nurture the talent of the  region, because that’s what it’s all about.”

It’s funny, but, because I know Mark, it’s  easier to see the real effect EAVE can have on a person. He walks taller, he  has more stature, because yes, he’s a producer now.

“I think I’ve probably just  taken a leap forward by six years. If I hadn’t done EAVE, I know it would have  taken me another six years to learn what I’ve just learned. When I went to the  first workshop back in January, I talked to a local producer who’d done it the  year before (Natasha Carlish, who recently produced the short film, Bouncer) and she said I’d come back to  Birmingham and immediately set up an office. I was like, you must be joking, I  can’t afford that, but she just smiled and said I would. So I do the first  workshop in Ludwigsburg and come straight back and take a unit in the Custard  Factory. I had to. You can’t be a producer without a production office.”

Doing the course has set him back a bit:  something like two grand from his pocket and maybe another three grand of work  that he had to turn down in order to do the festivals, but he got help to fund  some of it and he knows it’s an investment in his career. A year ago his  contacts book was full of regional talent and he was working on no-budget  shorts; now his contacts book is full of European producers and he’s talking to  the big money people about his feature idea. The next stage is to use those  European contacts to get movies off the ground in the West Midlands: a marriage  of continental and regional talent.

Mark is now doing business as Macoy Media.

Workshop 3, which took place largely at  Birmingham Rep, was hosted by Screen West Midlands and featured a number of  plenaries that were open to local producers. Of particular interest was the  talk given by Alison Small, Head of Film Council International, who pointed out  that inward-investment features in the UK are about to break all records.  There’s never been a better time to be a British producer looking for European  co-production partners to shoot a movie: “Global filmmaking is here to stay and  it’s not a threat to the UK that there are all these other fantastic filmmaking  centres across Europe: we should be working with each other in partnership.”

EAVE, then, seems like the perfect place to  start making those partnerships.


A version of this first appeared on Channel 4’s Ideasfactory site.

A little bit of soap…

Soap operas are the biggest employers of  scriptwriters on the market, they provide regular, well-paid work for writers,  are widely acknowledged to be the perfect training ground for any scriptwriter,  and they reach audiences that most movies can only dream of.

So why does every wannabe scriptwriter on  the block turn their nose up at soaps and dream about writing the next British  blockbuster?

Maybe it’s a snobbish thing. British  scriptwriting has always had a problem shaking off the deadly legacy of the theatre.  There’s still a class system in British scriptwriting circles that accepts that  the stage is the aristocracy, films are the vulgar middle classes and soaps are  shell-suited council estate trash.

But there’s also a truism to the old adage  that if Shakespeare were alive today he wouldn’t be writing stage plays, he’d  be churning out episodes of Eastenders (“A pox on thee, Phil Mitchell, thou baboon-faced wretch!”).

And yet, even though I’m a budding  scriptwriter myself, I don’t watch many soaps, so it was with trepidation that  I went along to Stagecoach’s soap writing workshop in Birmingham.

A lot of writers in the West   Midlands region had been demanding workshops focusing on writing  for TV, with a particular interest in soaps, so Stagecoach invited Hollyoaks writer Lucy Gough along. The  key aim of the day was to get into the nitty-gritty of what being a soap writer  really involves, with a particular emphasis on ‘storylining’ – that’s the  creating of story lines: crucial to any long-running soap.

Lucy’s  lucky break

Lucy always considered herself a stage and  radio writer until she spotted an article by Phil Redmond talking about a new  soap he was producing for teenagers, called Hollyoaks. At the time she’d written a number of plays for young  people, so she wrote to him, got an interview and found herself writing a trial  episode.

“The whole edginess of adolescence  fascinates me,” says Lucy. “I just love the contradictions. I love the way  adolescents think they’re immortal and yet are obsessed with death. And I  suppose because I had a baby in my teens as well, that part of my life was  quite memorable.”

A few years later and she has 70 episodes  under her belt. It seems like an incredibly lucky break but she insists it’s  not unusual. Perhaps the key thing to note is that she had a real passion for  the subject. Time and again, throughout the workshop, her key advice is know  all about the soap you want to write for: never try to fake it.

The fine  art of storylining

The workshop itself gets right to the heart  of what it takes to work on a soap like Hollyoaks.  Lucy shows an episode and then invites the group to come up with ideas for the  next day’s episode. This is an actual storylining conference: a group of  writers sitting round a table throwing in hundreds of ideas for what happens  next. After an hour of arguing, the four main storylines that will form the  next episode are all there and it’s time to split them into scenes.

At this point I lose my neutral observer  status and get roped into the process (they bullied me into it). We break the  stories down into the twenty-odd scenes that will form the episode, then each  of us has to pick a scene and write it. What really hits home with me at this  point is how sparse the dialogue has to be with soap writing. As the others  have their scenes read out I find myself crossing out whole chunks of dialogue  from mine, reducing speeches to monosyllables and nods. “It’s all in the subtext,  really,” says Lucy. “What’s going on emotionally is in the subtext. I suppose  partly it’s because it’s such a visual medium.”

By the end of the day I’ve emerged with a  much better idea of the skills you need to be a soap writer, and I get to interrupt  my flatmate’s viewing pleasure by knowingly harping on about the importance of hooks,  why those intro scenes with no dialogue at the start of the episode are called menu  scenes, why it’s always good to start a scene with an action, why you have to keep  characters moving in and out of scenes and, of course, why you must always end  on a question. I had to stop doing this when my flatmate started throwing  things at me.

The key mantra that stays with me, though,  is:

  • Know the programme
  • Know the characters
  • Know the shape and the tone of the programme

Time and again Lucy warns us never to try  and blag it. If you want to work for a particular soap, you should be watching  it. Sounds obvious, but it’s amazing how many writers apply for jobs on TV  dramas they don’t actually watch.

The characters  are crucial

Because soap writing is such a  collaborative enterprise, it’s a mixture of writing to order whilst slipping in  parts of your own voice. “Sometimes you’re working on stories that you don’t  know as well or don’t believe in as passionately as other stories. That’s where  you need inventiveness: you need to tap into something that you didn’t know you  had, to find a way into that story; stand on your head to try and find a new  way of looking at something.

“I think you can watch Hollyoaks and you  can say who’s written each episode because you can see their voice in there.  But at the same time there’s an evenness. The characters control how it’s  presented because the integrity of the characters is crucial. There are certain  perimeters within which you work: the characters, the profile of the programme,  and within that there’s room for your own voice.”

The day  to day

Not surprisingly, it involves a lot of meetings.  A storylining conference can last two days, with writers, producers and script  editors hammering out a series of episodes. A few days later you’re assigned  your very own episode.

You get about two weeks to write a first  draft, then the producers and script editors read them and invite you in for a  day to go through your script with the other writers of the same batch. You go  back home with notes for changes and do a second draft. Any third draft  problems are dealt with over the phone. Then you go over your script with your director  and get a day or two to make final changes. After that you won’t see it again  till it’s on TV.

Breaking  in

So what does it take to get onto the  Hollyoaks writing team?

“There are real opportunities to break in,”  says Lucy. “I think my timing was right, and that’s a lot of it, but the other  important thing is you have to be good at storylining. They want people who are  good at stories, that’s what they’re looking for, so you need to go in there  bubbling with ideas.”

To get an interview, you need to have  written at least one original script, something to give them an idea of your  style, so they can see if it suits their sort of programme.

When Lucy first started on Hollyoaks there  were only a few writers, but now there’s an 18-strong team. “They’re always on  the look out. The turnover isn’t massive because they’re a good company to work  for and people tend to stay, but there is some turnover, and also as more  episodes are being needed they have to bring in more writers.

“The important thing is if you want to do  it, go for it, because it’s not impossible. I would never have dreamt that I  could do it, but I am. That’s what people need to realise: if you really want  to do something, just stick at it and don’t think that any of these places are  citadels that you can’t get into because it’s just not true.”


A version of this first appeared on Channel 4’s Ideasfactory site.